Category Archives: Case teaching

What should higher education do about AI?

Herewith, a video and transcript of my inaugural lecture, on November 4th.

Chasing Scarcity in Teaching: Business Education in a Time of AI Disruption

Inaugural lecture of Teaching Professor Espen Andersen, BI Norwegian Business School, 4 November 2026

Lightly edited transcript:

Well, hi everyone. I’m not usually nervous when I teach, but I am now. Thank you all for coming. I was actually made a teaching professor a year and a half ago, but I got sick, so the whole thing got delayed. But thanks to all of you for coming here – family, friends, colleagues, former colleagues, members of Comunita, and members of my former class here at BI. We’re having a party this Friday, so I’m looking forward to that.

What I’m going to talk about is this notion of AI – what it is and how it affects teaching. And I’ll start by telling a story, which I tend to tell in all my courses as a sort of final story.

The best essay on innovation I have ever read was written by Elting Morison and published in 1950 – I think it was written some years before. It’s called “Gunfire at Sea”, and it is the story of a captain on a US Navy ship who made certain modifications to how they fired the guns and improved the accuracy from 8% to 74%. Which I think you’ll agree is pretty good. It took 30 years before the Navy adopted his innovations, and there were many reasons for that.

At the beginning of the essay, Morison tells this story about the guns. In the summer of 1940, France had fallen, Britain was basically fighting Germany on its own, and the danger of Hitler coming across the Channel was imminent. At the same time, Britain didn’t have weapons, because most of its heavy machinery and heavy weapons had been lost in France before the evacuation at Dunkirk. So they had to do something. And they had all these old guns, which looked like this – they’re called howitzers. So they pulled them out of storage, hitched them up to trucks, drove them down to the coast and pointed them towards the English Channel.

And then they said, “Wait a second, maybe we can improve the rate of fire using modern methods.” Now, modern methods at that time meant something called time and motion studies. You use film and a stopwatch, and you try to take away unnecessary movement. So they set up a gun, with eight men to man it and a sergeant to command. They followed the routines, fired the gun, and filmed it. Then they sat down and started to analyse the film.

And then the scientists saw something very weird. Right before the gun was fired – about three seconds before – two of the soldiers stood to attention, like that. And they stood to attention until the gun was fired, and a little while after. In terms of firing a gun as rapidly as possible, that is a fantastic waste of manpower.

So they thought, okay, we have to do something about that – but we are not going to change anything until we know why it is there. So they went to the sergeant, and he said, “Well, it’s procedure.” They followed the chain of command up, and finally they got to this old colonel. He should have been pensioned off a long time ago, but there’s a war on. He had actually been in the Boer War and in the First World War, when these guns had been used. So they dragged him in, plunked him down in front of the film projector, showed him the movie and said, “What’s going on here?” He looked at the movie and said, “Run the movie again.” He looked at it again and said, “I’ve got it. They’re holding the horses.”

But there aren’t any horses! And you can imagine: what are we going to do with those two soldiers for those seconds? Well, there are no horses to hold, so they’ll just stand there like this. Rather than changing what we do, we just continue to do what we’re doing and adapt it a little bit. Remember that story. I’m going to come back to it.

I’m going to talk a little bit about theory – very little theory. In fact, it’s not even theory. This is my framework. I made this, and I haven’t published it anywhere – maybe I should. But this is what I teach my students, and it goes like this: Technology changes the business environment. In fact, changes in technology are the primary change agent when businesses change. And when the business environment changes, we have to change our strategy. And I tell my students and executives, and anybody who wants to hear: wouldn’t it be nice to understand how technology changes, so that we can change our strategy before we’re forced to by the environment? That’s why I teach technology.

The trouble is, we don’t really know how technology influences organizations. When I came back from doing my doctorate and working in the States in 1996, I got into a debate about the productivity of information technology. Just as we now have the idea of AI and productivity – we see AI everywhere, everybody’s talking about how fantastic it is, but do we see any change in the productivity numbers? No. We had precisely the same debate over PCs back in ’96.

I got into a discussion with a researcher in Norway who had written in Aftenposten that there was no point in buying PCs, because he had timed how fast you wrote on a typewriter versus on a PC, and the difference was 10%, so the PC was not worth it. I wrote back and said: “I’m actually sitting on an airplane with my portable computer, typing this answer, and you’re absolutely correct – I can’t type much faster. But when I’m done, I can email this to Aftenposten and they can take it straight in.” Meaning that the productivity impact shows up in other places than where you measure it.

However, Aftenposten had something called typographers, and they had a union, and the union demanded that everything that came in electronically had to be retyped. So Aftenposten didn’t get the productivity benefit until they got rid of the typographers. Which teaches us that productivity shows up somewhere else in the whole supply chain, and you have to change your organization in order to reap the benefits.

Okay, that was the theory. Let’s talk about the technology that is changing things, and that technology is artificial intelligence. Trying to define artificial intelligence is more of a philosophy question than anything else. But I tend to divide it into three things – or most people do. We talk about analytical AI, generative AI and agentic AI. Analytical AI is sometimes called machine learning – think of it as the Excel department. Generative AI is the Word department, or the picture department. And agentic AI, where you have electronic agents doing something on your behalf, is perhaps the Teams department.

All of these are disruptive innovations in their own right. The main thing about a disruptive innovation is that the existing players in an industry are the least adaptive to the new technology.

So if you look at analytical AI, it challenges the traditional scientific method. In the traditional scientific method, Popper and other philosophers of science would say you have a theory, and from the theory you develop testable hypotheses. Then you collect the data and test the model, and maybe you validate it – but very often we don’t. Now, machine learning works like this: You have some data. You take 20% of the data and put it over here. Then you take the remaining 80% and tell the machine to find a model. And once it has found a model, you point it at the data it hasn’t seen yet and test how well it does. Can it predict whether there is cancer in this lesion? Can it predict how much this customer will buy? Can it predict how much we should pay for an ad on Google? The validation happens out of sample.

And once we have a model developed, we don’t have a theory. The reason we don’t have a theory is that, especially if you use neural networks, the model is so complicated that it’s humanly impossible to explain how it derives its decisions. And this is a challenge, because the skills that were good here – theory formation and so on – are not that good here.

How about generative AI? That’s what people mean when they talk about AI – ChatGPT and friends. There are many ways to think about it, but the way I look at it, it is a way of predicting the next word in a sentence, and a way of constructing something according to what is called a reward function. And the reward function tends to be what you’re happy with. I had a prospective doctoral student who told me that she was thinking of applying to BI because her AI therapist had told her to. And the AI therapist obviously tells her whatever she wants to hear.

I refer to it as hyper-efficient mediocrity, because AI can only do that which has been done before. It can do it very efficiently, and you can have an army of agents that do it for you, but it can’t come up with something that is genuinely new. So rather than try to explain it myself, I decided to just ask: what is hyper-efficient mediocrity? And it says that generative AI creates hyper-efficient mediocrity by automating routine white-collar tasks, such as answering basic questions, summarizing text and generating standard documentation of all kinds. And it’s very good at that. Where did it find that? Well, I wrote an article about it. And rather than summarize it myself, I just asked Google, and it summarized it for me. That’s what generative AI is good for. It does the simple work, leaving us to do the really valuable, really creative, really judgmental work. But it does it very well – and better and better.

One of the things it does is automate the simple work, and we’re now beginning to see that in the productivity numbers. This came from Erik Brynjolfsson at Stanford last week, I think, saying that if you now look at industries that are exposed to AI, we see lower hiring in the lower age brackets. Because the routine work normally done by younger people is increasingly being automated.

That challenges us, because it challenges the educational trajectory. Education used to look like this: We have the basics – you go to school. Then we have the specifics – you go to higher education. And once you come out of higher education, you have the tools and the theoretical knowledge, but you don’t yet have enough skill to apply it. That you have to learn as a junior person in a company. I’d say 95% of my students start in consulting, and they start at the lower level, doing very routine, hard work. And through doing so, they learn the skills that allow them to get more responsibility, experience and judgment.

Well, now we have a problem, because now we have AI and YouTube. I think it was ten years ago that I heard one of the people in the top management group say he had overheard students behind him on the subway saying, “I don’t go to classes. I just go to YouTube.” When I want to learn something new, like how a language model works, I go to YouTube. That’s what we’re competing against. And then we have AI, where students can now produce beautiful reports very, very quickly.

So you get the basics from school – but increasingly we see students dropping out of school. My wife Kristine is a real expert on people leaving school. (My clock talks to me.) It’s very complicated, but it seems that fewer and fewer people can deal with it. The specifics, higher education – well, increasingly online, and increasingly students are not getting the education they need, because they basically ask AI to do it. And now they can no longer get jobs. So where are they going to get the professional skills? Where is the next generation of experience and judgment going to come from?

There’s a little hint of an answer here: I think we need to move this training into what we do. There are two reasons for that. One is that these young people need to be educated to perform at a higher level when they come out, because companies can no longer afford that training period. But also, we need something more to do, because we’re being outcompeted by YouTube and AI and all that stuff. So we need to make what we do more real.

And then the last one: agentic AI, which does things on your behalf. What does that mean? We sort of divide AI into augmenting what you do – helping you get better – and that’s what most of us do. Most people here have grey hair; that’s what we do. But you can also use AI to replace people. Rather than hiring humans, we hire digital employees who go out and do things for us, and more and more people do that. And this could be the situation: “I’ll have my people talk to your people.” Well, they’re down here – some of them are human, some of them are digital.

By the way, this is a New Yorker cartoon, right? No, it’s not. I asked Gemini to make it. I specified it to Gemini. The signature you see down here is a mix of three or four artists who draw for The New Yorker. I should have put my own signature on it, but it didn’t feel right. That’s pretty good. I specified the joke, but it made the drawing.

How do you know that something is an agent? How do you know that you’re talking to a human? I’ve had that experience now – people calling me, and I have to figure out: are they real, or is this a fake? You’ve probably had that too. That was the woman I interviewed, because I thought she was fake. Turned out she was real – except she talked to her agent.

Now, we can have some sort of tests. Everybody has pressed this one: you click on it, and it figures out you are not a robot. It does that by analysing the way you move the mouse, because we cannot move it as precisely as a machine can. But sometimes you meet somebody… This is a friend of mine on Facebook. Her name is Tina Underhill. She lives on a farm in Suldal, in Rogaland. She works for a small software company called Aadnøy Labs, where she does all the accounting and things like that. She sometimes puts out pictures – when they have new lambs on the farm, or when she goes for a walk in the mountains. She’s not real.

She’s made by Alf Aadnøy. Alf is a member of the network of managers that I run with Haakon Gellein. He has programmed her and named her – his farm is named Underbakke, so she’s named Underhill. She does a lot of work for him, answers calls and does boring things like that. And he says that if he were making her all over again, he wouldn’t have made her so attractive, because he has to fend off a lot of not very welcome attention.

This is important for many companies. I’m not going to go into it – it’s not part of this – but a lot of competitive advantage online has been due to what we call network effects: consumer platforms. Take Finn, which has a 95% market share, and they get really antsy if their EBIT is below 40%. Then there’s a crisis in the house. I wish I was that lucky. Now they have a problem. We go to Finn because they have a 95% market share: if we want to sell something, that’s where the buyers are, and if we want to buy something, that’s where the sellers are. And we don’t bother with the smaller platforms. But if I have an agent that goes out and visits for me, I could go to Finn, I could go to Golsfjellet kjøp og salg, I could go to Facebook Marketplace – I could go anywhere, because the agent has infinite time and can just go out there. And that erodes something we thought was pretty permanent in the competitive world of the internet: network externalities.

So that’s that part: the impact on higher education.

That’s sort of the title of this whole thing: scarcity in teaching. What does that mean? Well, you can’t make money – money above normal profits – selling something that is available in abundance. You have to sell something that’s scarce. And AI can’t do creativity and judgment. It can’t come up with things that are truly new – yet. It can, through a process of self-complication, but it’s hard for it to come up with new things, and it’s very hard for it to exercise judgment. So we have to teach that. That’s a scarce skill we need to teach. How do we do that? That’s not easy.

The way I see it, it’s not easy because it requires a few things. It requires not just teaching students, but challenging them in an environment that is a simulation of what they’re going to meet after they’re done. It requires unpredictability. It requires that we don’t tell them what they’re going to learn, we don’t tell them how they’re going to do their exam, and we don’t tell them how they got their grade. Jan Ketil Arnulf has written an article called “Without unpredictability, higher education dies”. So we have to be unpredictable. And it requires making the classroom a place where the students and the instructor want to be – which I also stole from Jan Ketil.

So how do we do that? Well, I can only talk about what I do, because that’s my experience. But I have had students engaged. I have students who show up. I have students who take my courses. I don’t have drop-off in who comes to class. Quite a few of my colleagues do this as well, but they have different techniques. I can only talk about what I do.

And I prioritize having fun. That does not mean that the students have fun in the classroom – actually, they’re quite nervous. But I have fun. There are a couple of things we need to rethink. Students are product, not customers. Students come to me and say, I would like to do this by myself, I would like to do that. I had a student who came to me and said, “I have to leave early every Monday. Will that hit my participation grade?” I said, “Yes.” And he said, “But I have to go to work. I’m a professional football player.” I said, “No, you misunderstand. Every Monday, you will be 45 minutes late for practice.” And he said, “Can you speak to my trainer?” And I said, “No, I’m not your father. You do it yourself.” He actually showed up, and he became my teaching assistant the next year. Students respond to challenges, and we have to challenge them.

The second thing we need to think about is that BI is a health club, not a tanning salon. I’ve stolen that one from Øyvind Revang, who used to teach here. Students think we’re going to come in and sit down and sit like this, and then we’re going to get a nice tan and a diploma that shows we have a tan, and then we can go. That’s not how it works. BI is a place where you can train and practise and get better, and it’s going to be painful and require something.

For a long time I have wanted to write an article called “What can higher education learn from Kompani Lauritzen?” For those who are not Norwegian, this is a TV programme where they take civilians in. It’s a reality show where they put them through a boot camp, and they meet this guy – I’ve forgotten his name, but he’s known in Norway as Fenriken. That’s with a capital F; it means the second lieutenant. He comes in and tells the people who are there what they’re going to do, how they’re going to do it, what the limits are, and what is considered acceptable and unacceptable behaviour and performance. He does it in a supportive but firm way, and he says wonderful things. My favourite one is this: people complain, “But I did wash my room,” and he says, “We’re not looking for the activity of washing. We’re looking for the result: clean.” I think we can learn a lot from Kompani Lauritzen.

I know one guy who has this attitude – my colleague Hanno Roberts. He is frequently voted the best professor in our Chinese programmes and others. When he comes in, he has a T-shirt on, and on the T-shirt it says “No pain, no gain”. That’s the right attitude, and that’s what we need to do, I think – or at least it has worked for me.

So how do we do that? Well, you basically have to force students. You have to force them to participate. You have to force them to prepare. I have something called prepared presence. In my courses you have to show up for 70% of the classes in order to qualify, but it is a prepared presence. So I can say, “Birgitte, please introduce this case for us” – she’s my boss, by the way – and if she says, “I didn’t read the case today,” I say, “Okay, you weren’t here today. You’re marked as not present.” Because you have to force people to prepare, and they do instrumental work.

You have to force them to work in groups. You get students who say, “But I want to do this project by myself.” And I say, “No, that’s not an option. It’s written in.” And we force students to solve real problems. Every year, when Chandler and I do our machine learning course, we have students who say, “But I want to work with a data set that’s already available.” And we say, you have to work with a real data set, because real data sets are not clean or well defined, or even available. Half the work for a data scientist is actually getting the data into a shape where you can analyse it. You have to force them to touch the dirty reality, and there are no exceptions.

Here’s a technique I learned from a colleague – I’ll get back to him later. When the students choose their term papers, this is the way we do it. Every student makes a handwritten poster where they present what they want to write about: which company, which problem they want to solve, and so on. They all present; it takes a minute or two each, depending on how many students we have. As soon as you’ve finished presenting, we glue the piece of paper up on the wall, so we have all these posters along the wall. When everybody’s done, everybody goes up and stands in front of their poster. I ask people to notice where everybody is, and then I declare the market open. And you have to find a group, and you have to do it there. That’s engagement. When I do that, two minutes later the classroom looks like this. And that’s what you want to see: students actively engaging, finding problems. And you have to force them to do it.

Another thing I do is that I tend not to emphasize theory, because theory you can find in other courses, and you can also find it online or elsewhere. It’s kind of normal to have a guest lecture or two. I do a lot more. This semester I have four courses, and these are the guest lectures booked so far. I go out and recruit all these business people and have them come in, and I don’t ask them to teach. I ask them to talk about what they do. So I asked Geir Karlsen, what’s it like to run Norwegian, and how did you manage to turn it around? Or I asked Torstein Berg how he’s been able to start and fund three or four very successful companies. Or I talked to Andreas Solbakken about his serial entrepreneurship since he was 16 years old. And these people come back, because they’re asked not to be teachers but to be business people. The whole thing is about providing an experience in the classroom that you can’t get online or through AI.

And then I collaborate, and I experiment with masters. I never teach alone. That’s expensive, again, so you’re going to have to fund this. But courses get much better if there are two of you. If you’ve ever listened to a podcast, you know there are two people, because they talk to each other and it becomes a conversation. And I find masters I can collaborate with.

So I have a master of interaction: the best case teacher I’ve ever met. His name is Bill Schiano. He’s not here; he’s at Bentley University. In 1996 we put together a course where we did video teaching across the Atlantic and had the students form groups across the Atlantic to solve business problems. That got us into Aftenposten, and eventually we wrote a book together called Teaching with Cases, with all sorts of tips and tricks for how to get this engagement.

Then I have a master of relevance – somebody who really knows business and can provide relevance. Her name is Berit Svendsen. When Berit resigned her job as CEO of Telenor Norway, I heard it on the radio, and I stopped the car and called Inge Jan Henjesand, the former president, and said, “Hire her.” And it’s the only time he has listened to me. We do a course called Det verdiskapende styret together, and I shamelessly use Berit for her relevance and her business connections. The first class we taught, she said, “I have to leave early, because there’s something going on.” We were teaching board management – and the day after, it was in the newspaper that she had become Board Chair of the Year.

I have a master of explanation. His name is Chandler Johnson. I didn’t know anything about machine learning – or I knew a little bit; I knew statistics – but I wanted to learn. And the best way to learn something is to do a course in it. So I set up a course in analytics, which gave Chandler access to business people and me access to Chandler. Now we’ve done it ten times, and now I can teach machine learning. That’s how you do it.

I have a master of diplomacy. His name is Stein Gjessing. For seven years I wanted to do a course that mixed real technology – computer science from the Department of Informatics at the University of Oslo – with the business part delivered by BI: the biggest university in Norway and the biggest business school, two stops away from each other on the train. How hard can it be? Turned out, very hard. But Stein shepherded this through a very sceptical faculty at the University of Oslo. I was not so successful shepherding it through a very sceptical organization here locally. So we had to do it at the university, and we called it Digital Economics and Management – first a bachelor’s, then a master’s – and it became Norway’s most popular programme: 3,000 applicants for 27 places. I got calls from parents saying, “Can you get my daughter in?” It’s still the most popular programme at the institute, and we made the front page of Dagens Næringsliv.

And last but not least, I have a master of innovation, and his name is Ragnvald Sannes – a master of innovation in teaching. We have done a lot of things together. He’s an expert in the process of setting up a course, and this whole process I use, of having students choose a project early and shepherding them through the whole class, I learned from him – including this trick with all the posters. If you want to see a really nice classroom, go and look at the Ragnvald Sannes auditorium, which is just over here. It hasn’t got that sign on the wall yet, but it will.

We have created lots of courses. The one that has been the most fun was the course we ran for 20 years called Strategic Business Development and Innovation. We did that together with Accenture in Sophia Antipolis, a technology park in the south of France. The side effect, of course, was that every October we had to go to Antibes for a week or two – and Egil was paying for it, or his predecessors – and we went with our wives and with Ellen Heggelund, who is a master course arranger. We did that for 20 years. It was a pain, but somebody had to do it…

What should higher education and BI do? Well, here’s a little list to think about. Here’s the thing: BI is already doing a lot. I’m not as worried about BI as I am about other institutions of higher learning. And the reason is very simple: we do not have two billion kroner in foundational funding. We have to – and we’re doing quite a bit.

We have a word called employability, which Egil has put on the agenda. That means we need to care a lot about our students getting jobs, because that is our contract. If you don’t know what to do, go to BI – you will get a job. That’s our unwritten contract. So employability is now on the agenda. What it is, I don’t know, but it’s on the agenda.

Secondly, we’re doing something called Doing Sustainable Business. I was going to be involved with it, but I got sick, and that really saddens me, because it is a fantastic course. It’s the final course at the end of the bachelor programme. It has three and a half thousand students doing cases in groups across study disciplines. And here’s the thing: I was at Harvard Business School about three years ago, discussing case teaching with them, and they talked about this programme and said nobody is doing that. We’re the only school in the world that does that. 70 faculty are involved. This is great. It’s expensive, Egil, so you’re going to have to continue funding it, because it’s important.

We have this building. This building has classrooms where the students can see each other. This building is beautiful. This building is interactive. This building is clean. When I go to certain other institutions, I have to bring my own markers, because there are no markers in the classroom. Here, people test the markers every morning to make sure they work. We have the infrastructure. People go to other institutions in Oslo, look around at brutalist concrete buildings, and then they come here and think, “Hmm – the next five years of my life.” This building is, if not the most important, at least the most visible competitive advantage we have. I’ve tried to do case teaching in classrooms where students can only look straight ahead. That’s not easy. We have U-shaped classrooms. We have the technology, we have the infrastructure, and we understand the severity of the problem. And that’s important.

But we need to change things, and here are the things I think we need to change. We need to change recruitment and rewards. We need to reward teaching, teaching innovation and teaching development as much as we do research. Why is it called “undervisningsplikt”? Get rid of that word. It’s something you do – it’s the main thing we do.

We must change the innovation process from stage-gate to experimental. When I teach innovation – or rather, when Ragnvald teaches innovation – we talk about old processes, where you come up with an idea, present it to a committee, and they decide yes or no; and more modern processes, where you develop a prototype and test it in the market. And it’s kind of weird to me that we are using the old model and not the new one. Because almost all innovation at BI has happened because somebody just did it. One of the reasons we rank so high is that we have a Chinese programme, and the Chinese programme was done by a couple of faculty who just went there and did it. There was no formal gate process. So we have to be able to experiment.

We must oppose regulation that shackles innovation. One of the problems we have with AI is that we need to change the way we do evaluation. If you go to Harvard, MIT, IMD, INSEAD, Darden or London Business School, you’re evaluated based on what you say in the classroom. In Norway, we’re not allowed to do that. The best universities in the world do it. We must do something about that. We must stop this notion that grading is a controllable and measurable process. It is opinion.

And we must tolerate innovation even if we don’t like it – even if we don’t like the person. Remember that article about the guns? One of the reasons it took 30 years was that the guy who improved gunnery from 7% to 80%, or something like that, was an arrogant bastard. Nobody liked him. Another reason was that he had the gunner decide himself when to fire, rather than an officer saying “fire”. You had to compensate for the ship rolling, and the gunner could actually do that – which meant transferring the decision right from the people who traditionally had it. We can’t do that. We have to test in the market and then do what works.

So what we essentially have to do – and I’ve used this term many times, but I think it’s very, very important – is protect the future from the past. Otherwise, we end up holding horses.

Thank you very much!

Reflections on designing a new board competency course

Time for some reflection after having designed and taught the new EMM (Executive Master of Management) course “The Value-Creating Board”, arranged for the first time in the fall of 2024.

The course has been a pleasure to develop and teach. As of today, BI has a number of basic management courses, either alone or in collaboration with institutions such as the Norwegian Confederation of Trade Unions (NHO) or the Norwegian Agricultural Cooperative. With the change in Norwegian law requiring at least 40% of each gender on boards – which will require around 10,000 new, female board members – it was natural to offer a board member course within BI’s Executive Master of Management program, which already has a high proportion of women.

When I develop courses, I do not start from a subject area, but rather from a description of “that”jobs” the student should be able to perform when the course is completed. I wanted to train people who could participate in boards of directors for developing companies, where the board’s role is both to have control over what is happening and to ensure focus on strategy and the future. In pedagogy, this is called ” constructive alignment ” – that is, you develop courses and teaching materials based on what is important for the students to learn (the learning objectives), not based on what you yourself want to lecture on or what is common within the subject area.

There are some things you just can’t avoid in a board course. You need to have something about legal matters – you can never escape board responsibility, and the Companies Act gives the board mandates and tasks that are not to be avoided. As I tell my students: Legal matters are not important until they are, at which point they are all that matters. You also need to have some financial knowledge – it doesn’t help to tell the Bankruptcy Court or the Tax Directorate that you’re not that good at (or interested in) accounting when your equity has evaporated. The rest is a mix of strategy, management and understanding external changes, such as new technology, the almost exploding AI, and ESG reporting and integration).

People who recruit for boards look for two things: management experience and domain knowledge. Both are knowledge areas where you can learn some principles and frameworks through textbooks, but in a board context you have to be able to put things into practice, and then you should have experience using the knowledge, not just reproducing it.

What should the course include?

Given that a board course can be everything and nothing – because the board is responsible for the entire company, without the mandate to go into the details – I chose to define the content of the course by recruiting a great team , who then contributed what they knew best.

The most important person to recruit was definitely Berit Svendsen , who I wanted as a development partner and co-teacher. Berit is the former CEO of Telenor Norway, and as extensive experience as a top manager, board member and chairperson. Berit has been present for most of the course, has contributed with comments, presentations, guidance and not least by letting me draw on her fantastic network. To top it all, she was named Board Chair of the year during the course, which certainly provides unmatched legitimacy!

I found the rest of the team at BI: Thomas Borgen, former CEO of Danske Bank and Board Chair of Kongsberg Digital, contributed his experience and network of contacts both as a senior manager and board member, as well as interesting lectures on the role of the board in strategy execution and risk management. Tore Bråthen, perhaps Norway’s foremost authority on corporate law, contributed his unparalleled legal expertise on board responsibilities, as well as a thorough and reflective perspective on what the new sustainability regulation entails. And Ketil Hveding contributed the basic, but oh so important economic understanding and a perspective on the challenges of small and medium-sized enterprises. Ketil also plays a key role in taking things from BI’s existing management course into this course. I also look forward to taking some of what we – and the students – have worked on and using it to enrich the courses we already have. And not least: I asked nicely to have Mari Berg Henie as the course coordinator – she is not just structured and knowledgeable, but also the koordinator of my other Exec courses, which makes life considerably easier for all involved.

Otherwise, the course has drawn on a great set of guest speakers, both to provide a grounded perspective on what it means to sit on a value-creating board, but also to lay a foundation for further development of the course: It is only when you hear from those who have the shoes on that you know what is important and relevant. (Constructive alignment, again…).

Guest speakers have been:

  • Eivind Reiten, who spoke about the relationship with the owners. Eivind is the chairman of the board of directors of, among others, the Kongsberg group and one of Norway’s most experienced board and business leaders. His perspective on how to relate to owners – he has been widely criticized because he does not want to take dictation from state owners – was particularly interesting because he based his argument not on politics, but on the Norwegian Companies Act, which states that one cannot treat owners differently, and that a claim from an owner, however large, requires a decision from a general assembly. He taught the students that the board has decision-making authority that must be used on behalf of all “stakeholders” of a company, not just owners.
  • Gyrid Skalleberg Ingerø is a former CFO of Telenor and the Kongsberg Group and an extremely experienced board member. She shared her vast experience, very concretely, about what one should and should not do as a valuable board member, down to details about how to stay updated on competitors, industry and technology, how to handle conflicting interests, finances, and risk. Not least, she gave good advice on what to think about if you are offered a board position, including the risks it entails (and which are rarely talked about).
  • Øystein Moan, former CEO and now working chairman of the Visma Group, participated in a webinar from his new home in Switzerland, and spoke about Visma’s development, strategy and his role as working chairman (a role that is quite unusual in Norway, at least for larger companies.) He demonstrated how strategy formulation, learning and execution in a long-term perspective yields results – and provided good perspectives from a corporate strategic view, for instance by having interlocking board memberships for subsidiaries, seen from a board and senior management perspective.
  • Jan-Erik Hareid, founder and managing partner of the early growth stage venture capital company Alliance Venture, spoke about the phases of a company’s development and what you look for in board members in the different phases. He gave the investor perspective, and talked a lot about the importance of recruiting and following up on the people who will actually develop companies.
  • Thomas Evensen is CEO of OrgBrain , which is both a scale-up company (and thus interesting with the board challenges that entails), but also a company providing a digital platform for board work. This gives him first-hand insight into the many dilemmas that boards of directors in small and medium-sized companies have to deal with. And he gave us just that: What is happening in small companies, what do they have to deal with – and how can they recruit and use board members when they have fewer resources (people and money) to do things formally?

Case as term paper

Board work is, in my view, basically problem-solving, best learned through solving many problems and eventually developing an ability to recognize things and apply experience from one problem to another. I use case teaching to teach the students this – but there are not many cases about board work today, either internationally or in Norway. That is why I have chosen to let the students’ project assignments be to create cases – find a business that is facing a challenge where the board must get involved, the problem is complicated, and there are several alternative measures to choose from.

The students have responded very well, I must say, and the case list looks like this:

  • a nationally critical internet and telecom provider that experiences an outage of half of its capacity, possibly due to sabotage, and must figure out the board’s role before, during and after such an event.
  • a small IT services company struggling with growth in a tight financial situation, having to consider both professionalizing the board and management, and using co-ownership to recruit and retain the right resources.
  • a manufacturing company, the cornerstone of a small community, that is experiencing a weak economy and that the corporation that owns them is starting to talk about closing it down.
  • a trading company in the cosmetics and wellness sector that sees new competitors on the horizon, and must consider whether the incumbent board – consisting of old friends – and strategy are appropriate in a world where things are not as easy and pleasant anymore.
  • a family-owned manufacturing company that finds their newly appointed general manager – with extensive experience in the company – resigning his position to move to a newly established competitor, on significantly better terms.
  • a small, independent bank that must consider whether it is possible to continue as a small, independent and local business in a world where new, costly requirements for reporting and resource use (sustainability, anti-money laundering, cybersecurity) are constantly increasing and can more easily be borne by a larger business or through an alliance.
  • A small specialist healthcare provider that must decide whether to be a non-profit or a commercial enterprise, with the organizational and cultural changes that will entail. The situation creates a divided board, and the chairman must navigate a complicated landscape.
  • A water park started as a public-private partnership must balance between the stock market and the cathedral: Should it focus on commercial activity or continue a riskier existence as a primary public welfare service?
  • A company developing electric aircraft must make difficult strategic choices in relation to technology development, investors, and the market situation.
  • A company that provides infrastructure services must consider that some of their employees (and employees within subcontractor companies) may be classified as a security risk because they come from certain countries, or have family members who do. The board and management must consider what measures can be taken, balancing national security considerations with employee rights.
  • A small company that has developed a software system is struggling to get out of the “valley of death,” a situation that is not made any easier by insisting that it is in a scale-up phase without having profitable customers. A potential chairperson must decide whether this is something to invest in or not – and whether to take the position at all.

Exam

In addition to the cases, I have – for the first time in many years – held a “closed book” exam, where students come in, take an exam without aids (they use PCs with a locked browser.) I don’t like traditional exams – they are expensive, the pedagogical effect is debatable, and they introduce possible complications (students who for some reason cannot get to the exam venue, technical difficulties, etc.) and unnecessary stress. However, BI is obliged to maintain some control over whether the students – individually – have actually learned something. Group assignments introduce the possibility of free riders, home exams can be solved by ChatGPT and other large language models.

So, exam it was. I chose to make it with relatively simple and clear questions, about key topics in the course (“What does it mean that equity has been lost, and what is the board’s responsibility in such a situation”). The purpose of an exam is simply to check that the students have understood the main points of the course, not to get bogged down in esoteric details. That is why I also plan for the students to be given a certain number (5, this time) of questions, of which they will have to answer a smaller number (this time 4). This prevents the student from sitting there and not remembering some detail or another and feeling crushed because of it.

Further development

Post-implementation, we have found the course content to be fairly complete – no haven’t found any major gaps in the curriculum or things that absolutely should have been included. If anything, we should perhaps have more about companies in development phases, something about board membership remuneration and opportunities to use stock options and other mechanisms for adjusting goals and incentives for the board and management. We should also have more practical information about sustainability and sustainability reporting, and also something more about how a board should relate to and actually do before and in a bankruptcy situation. Theory-wise, we could have had more about principal-agent issues (in addition to discussions about corporate governance), but the theoretical apparatus there often ends up in situations that are relatively esoteric from a Norwegian perspective.

The most important element will be to develop learning activities that allow students to gain some form of experience of board work and board assessments. I believe in case teaching, and several of the cases described above have the potential to become very good teaching cases, which are in short supply. The process around writing the cases (which I will continue) could be tightened up and better documented.

The course will next be held in the fall of 2025. Some feedback from students is on LinkedIn ( here , here , here and here , for example.)

I’m really looking forward to the next time – and if you need good board members, I have many good candidates to offer!

ETP (Excellent Teaching Practitioner)

In May I received official message that I had been awarded the status of Excellent Teaching Practitioner with four colleagues from BI.

To cite an official description: “The excellent teaching practitioner (ETP) status is granted based upon proven merit and commitment to teaching and educational excellence. The ETP is independent of other academic promotion schemes, and the title ETP can only be awarded to people who develop their teaching competences systematically and over time to a level that is significantly higher than the required basic competence at Universities.” The program has existed at other schools for a few years, but this is the first year BI awards it.

I thought I would use this space to reflect a bit on the whys and hows of this status change – as well as the process, to encourage more of my colleagues to seek it.

Why apply for ETP?
I have always cared about the teaching part of the job, partly because I am better at that than publications, partly because I think quality in teaching is an important differentiator for higher education institutions in general and business school in particular. We need good teaching. BI, a private institution competing with practically gratis public institutions, need it more than ever.

While focusing on teaching is great for your life quality and sense of purpose, it is a killer in terms of more material rewards. You will not get promoted to full professor by being a good teacher and publishing on teaching (at least not in Norway: My excellent colleague Bill Schiano was promoted to full professor at Bentley in 2015 in no small measure because of the book we wrote together.) Good teaching will be rewarded with nice words and rather quickly evaporating brownie points, illiquid outside your own institution. Unless you shift over to becoming a professor of pedagogy (i.e., change careers) you will have to take your rewards intrinsically (happy students and good experiences in the classroom) or outside the institution (consulting, speaking, board memberships etc.).

Prestige?
Apparently (and I can’t find the quote, ChatGPT or not) a cantankerous old editor of The Times disallowed the word “famous” when describing someone. The reason was that if the person was famous, the word was unnecessary – and if not, incorrect.

So I am a little puzzled that the ETP is referred to as “prestigious” in the announcement. However, some really good teachers, such as my friend Arne Krokan at NTNU, has been awarded it (he was one reason I applied, actually). And I certainly feel proud when my photo appears next to my colleagues above. That is prestigious, at least to me.

The ETP status, however, carries some tangible benefits aside from whatever prestige it may confer: A (modest) salary increase, permanent and applicable towards your pension. While the sum is not large, it is high enough that it makes the process of applying worth doing in itself. (The salary increase certainly does not pay for the extra effort you have put into your teaching over the years, but it is not intended to.)

A second, and perhaps more important consideration is that the pendulum in academia has swung very far out on the research & publication end, and is now coming back towards teaching & relevance, particularly for business schools. The ETP status is something implemented by the government and adopted by BI to shift focus towards quality in teaching – and if nobody applies for it, it loses value.

So, dear colleagues with excellent experience with innovative teaching – yes, I am looking at you Ragnvald, Øystein, Hanno, Anna, Pål, Robert and doubtless many others – do go ahead and apply!

That will increase my prestige!

And now for the process:

The application itself
To help people apply for ETP, BI has created an internal web page and sought the help of a consultant (Prof. Trine Fossland) to advise applicants. I had two video sessions with Trine, and she helped me structure my application. The application is quite comprehensive, and it is good advice to take out as much of your documented experience as possible (that goes into the pedagogical CV, which, if you have not created it gradually over the years, is quite a bit of work in itself.)

Writing an application is an exercise in focus: You need to show that you fulfil the criteria, that the evolution and innovation you have done is a planned activity, consciously undertaken, and that you can credibly claim to want to continue it. You need to pick a few activities and show their change over time.

For me this was difficult – I have never had a plan with what I do, but a constant dissatisfaction with my courses (I really should do better) and an appetite for new technology and new ways of doing things has helped me maintain an innovative pressure. I try to explain that I put a lot of work into my courses because I am inherently lazy and want to work as efficiently as possible, but that excuse is wearing a bit thin.

Innovation comes from trying things at the edge. I have always been someone who wants to try things out, often by “breaking” rules or at least tradition – such as currently teaching a course at UiO and BI at the same time, mixing the students. The students love it (and have asked med to force cross-institutional teams the next time I teach it), the administration at the operative level are helpful, but you do run into a lot of “this is how we do it here” issues, often expressed as pedagogical principles that as a rule are neither pedagogical nor principled.

At some point I really need to write that “Innovators are irritating” paper I have been thinking about for so long…

Pedagogical course requirement
Midway through the process (actually, after the application was submitted) I discovered that one of the criteria was that I had to have the basic education course (Utdanningsfaglig kompetanse) that all newly hired faculty at BI must take. That was kind of a bummer and in my view an unnecessary formality: I have learned and taught pedagogy at HBS and many other places around the world and taught classes since 1983. Luckily, there was an option for highly experienced faculty to basically take a home exam based on the curriculum in the course, which duly did. This required writing and submitting a teaching portfolio – a mix of a short pedagogical CV, as well as a short paper reflecting on your teaching as seen through the curriculum of the course.

Initially I saw this basic pedagogy exercise as an irritant (and, to be honest, slightly humiliating), but looking back on it, I cannot say it was a totally useless endeavor. The Learning Center (Inger Carin, in my case), was very helpful. It acquainted me with some literature – and language – of pedagogy. I found that what I had been doing over the years was recommended by the pedagogues, though it must be said that pedagogy professors never use one sentence when a few chapters or a whole book can be written instead.

In the end, it allowed me with some justification to say that what I do is grounded in theory, though I discovered at least some of the theory after a couple of decades of teaching…

The panel interview
The final stage of the process was an interview by a committee of assessors (professors from other institutions in Norway, all of them ETPs in their own right). I have not done many job interviews and have not done well in any of them, but apparently I passed well enough, and the report afterwards was very complimentary.

One thing I do remember was that my main teaching approach – HBS-style case teaching, where the students are supposed to do the talking and every class is a case-based class, with participation grading, fixed seating and other features – was not something the committee was familiar with (or maybe they were, and just wanted me to explain it.) I also got the feeling that the committee was not very familiar with executive teaching in a business school context.

My main advice to those of you wanting to go through the same process is to not take any knowledge about what you do for granted, but explain it and put it into a context. I did the usual smart thing and tried to check out the backgrounds and pedagogical focus of the committee members, but still managed to miss the mark a bit. However, they were friendly and pulled me back on track.

In conclusion
Well, there you go: A worthwhile exercise to go through to get some tangible rewards for doing the thing you love and would do anyway. Now it remains to see if this exalted status will bring reputational immortality or exciting new opportunities…

How to do a research interview

Here is a little video I did on how to do a research interview.

30 minutes long, fairly straightforward, I now have the technology sorted that I can make videos like this fairly easy and with decent quality. Might have used a better microphone, but what the heck, it works and only took me about four hours, including writing the outline.

As usual with these things: Caveat emptor. But this approach works for me.

Outline posted below the fold.

Continue reading →

Getting dialogue online

Bank in the nineties, I facilitated a meeting with Frank Elter at a Telenor video meeting room in Oslo. There were about 8 participants, and an invited presenter: Tom Malone from MIT.

The way it was set up, we first saw a one hour long video Tom had created, where he gave a talk and showed some videos about new ways of organizing work (one of the more memorable sequences was (a shortened version of) the four-hour house video.) After seeing Tom’s video, we spent about one hour discussing some of the questions Tom had raised in the video. Then Tom came on from a video conferencing studio in Cambridge, Massachusetts, to discuss with the participants.

The interesting thing, to me, was that the participants experienced this meeting as “three hours with Tom Malone”. Tom experienced it as a one hour discussion with very interested and extremely well prepared participants.

A win-win, in other words.

I was trying for something similar yesterday, guest lecturing in Lene Pettersen‘s course at the University of Oslo, using Zoom with early entry, chat, polling and all video/audio enabled for all participants. This was the first videoconference lecture for the students and for three of my colleagues, who joined in. In preparation, the students had read some book chapters and articles and watched my video on technology evolution and disruptive innovations.

For the two hour session, I had set up this driving plan (starting at 2 pm, or 14:00 as we say over here in Europe…):

Image may contain: Espen Andersen, eyeglasses

Leading the discussion. Zoom allows you to show a virtual background, so I chose a picture of the office I would have liked to have…

14:00 – 14:15 Checking in, fiddling with the equipment and making sure everything worked. (First time for many of the users, so have the show up early so technical issues don’t eat into the teaching time.)
14:15 – 14:25 Lene introduces the class, talks about the rest of the course and turns over to Espen (we also encouraged the students to enter questions they wanted addressed in the chat during this piece)
14:25 – 14:35 Espen talking about disruption and technology-driven strategies.
14:35 – 14:55 Students into breakout rooms – discussing whether video what it would take for video and digital delivery to be a disruptive innovation for universities. (Breaking students up into 8 rooms of four participants, asking them to nominate a spokesperson to take notes and paste them into the chat when they return, and to discuss the specific question: What needs to happen for COVID-19 to cause a disruption of universities, and how would such a disruption play out?
14:55 – 15:15 Return to main room, Espen sums up a little bit, and calls on spokesperson from each group (3 out of 8 groups) based on the notes posted in the chat (which everyone can see). Espen talks about the Finn.no case and raises the next discussion question.
15:15 – 15:35 Breakout rooms, students discuss the next question: What needs to happen for DNB (Norway’s largest bank) to become a data-driven, experiment-oriented organization like Finn.no? What are the most important obstacles and how should they be dealt with?
15:35 – 15:55 Espen sums up the discussion, calling on some students based on the posts in the chat, sums up.
15:55 – 16:00 Espen hand back to Lene, who sums up. After 16:00, we stayed on with colleagues and some of the students to discuss the experience.

zoom dashboard

The dashboard as I saw it. Student names obscured.

Some reflections (some of these are rather technical, but they are notes to myself):

  • Not using Powerpoint or a shared screen is important. Running Zoom in Gallery view (I had set it up so you could see up to 49 at the same time) and having the students log in to Zoom and upload a picture gave a feeling of community. Screen and/or presentation sharing breaks the flow for everyone – When you do it in Zoom, the screen reconfigures (as it does when you come back from a breakout room) and you have to reestablish the participant panel and the chat floater. Instead, using polls and discussion questions and results communicated through the chat was easier for everyone (and way less complicated).
  • No photo description available.

    Satisfactory results, I would say.

    I used polls on three occasions: Before each discussion breakout, and in the end to ask the students what the experience was like. They were very happy about it and had good pointers on how to make it better

  • We had no performance issues and rock-steady connection the whole way through.
  • It should be noted that the program is one of the most selective in Norway and the students are highly motivated and very good. During the breakout sessions I jumped into each room to listen in on the discussion (learned that it was best to pause recording to avoid a voice saying “This session is being recorded” as I entered. The students were actively discussing in every group, with my colleagues (Bendik, Lene, and Katja) also participating. I had kept the groups to four participants, based on feedback from a session last week, where the students had been 6-7 and had issues with people speaking over each other.
  • Having a carefully written driving plan was important, but still, it was a very intense experience, I was quite exhausted afterwards. My advice on not teaching alone stands – in this case, I was the only one with experience, but that will change very fast. But I kept feeling rushed and would have liked more time, especially in the summary sections, would have liked to bring more students in to talk.
  • I did have a few breaks myself – during the breakout sessions – to go to the bathroom and replenish my coffee – but failed to allow for breaks for the students. I assume they managed to sneak out when necessary (hiding behind a still picture), but next time, I will explicitly have breaks, perhaps suggest a five minute break in the transition from main room to breakout rooms.

Conclusion: This can work very well, but I think it is important to set up each video session based on what you want to use it for: To present something, to run an exercise, to facilitate interaction. With a small student group like this, I think interaction worked very well, but it requires a lot of presentation. You have to be extremely conscious of time – I seriously think that any two-hour classroom session needs to be rescheduled to a three hour session just because the interaction is slower, and you need to have breaks.

As Winston Churchill almost said (he said a lot, didn’t he): We make our tools, and then our tools make us. We now have the tools, it will be interesting to see how the second part of this transition plays out.

A teaching video – with some reflections

Last Thursday, I was supposed to teach a class on technology strategy for a bachelor program at the University of Oslo. That class has been delayed for a week and (obviously) moved online. I thought about doing it video conference, but why not make a video, ask the students to see it before class? Then I can run the class interactively, discussing the readings and the video rather than spending my time talking into a screen. Recording a video is more work, but the result is reusable in other contexts, which is why I did it in English, not Norwegian. The result is here:

To my teaching colleagues: The stuff in the middle is probably not interesting – see the first two and the last five minutes for pointers to teaching and video editing.

For the rest, here is a short table of contents (with approximate time stamps):

  • 0:00 – 2:00 Intro, some details about recording the video etc.
  • 2:00 – 27:30 Why technology evolution is important, and an overview of technology innovation/evolution processes
    • 6:00 – 9:45 Standard engineering
    • 9:45 – 12:50 Invention
    • 12:50 – 15:50 Structural deepening
    • 15:50 – 17:00  Emerging (general) technology
      • 17:00 – 19:45 Substitution
      • 19:45 – 25:00 Expansion, including dominant design
      • 25:00 – 27:30 Structuration
  • 27:30 – 31:30 Architectural innovation (technology phases)
  • 31:30 –  31:45 BREAK! (Stop the video and get some coffee…)
  • 31:45 – 49:40 Disruption
    • 31:45 – 38:05 Introduction and theory
    • 38:05 – 44:00 Excavator example
    • 44:00 – 46:00 Hairdresser example
    • 47:00 – 47:35 Characteristics of disruptive innovations
    • 47:35 – 49:40 Defensive strategies
  • 49:40 – 53:00 Things take time – production and teaching…
  • 53:00 – 54:30 Fun stuff

This is not the first time I have recorded videos, by any means, but it is the first time I have created one for “serious” use, where I try to edit it to be reasonably professional. Some reflections on the process:

  • This is a talk I have given many times, so I did not need to prepare the content much – mainly select some slides. for a normal course, I would use two-three hours to go through the first 30 minutes of this video – I use much deeper examples and interact with the students, have them come up with other examples and so on. The disruption part typically takes 1-2 hours, plus at least one hour on a specific case (such as the steel production). Now the format forces me into straight presentation, as well as a lot of simplification – perhaps too much. I aim to focus on some specifics in the discussion with the students.
  • I find that I say lots of things wrong, skip some important points, forget to put emphasis on other points. That is irritating, but this is straight recording, not a documentary, where I would storyboard things, film everything in short snippets, use videos more, and think about every second. I wanted to do this quickly, and then I just have to learn not to be irritated at small details.
  • That being said, this is a major time sink. The video is about 55 minutes long. Recording took about two hours (including a lot of fiddling with equipment and a couple of breaks). Editing the first 30 minutes of the  video took two hours, another hour and a half for the disruption part (mainly because by then I was tired, said a number of unnecessary things that I had to remove.)
  • Using the iPad to be able to draw turned out not to be very helpful in this case, it complicated things quite a bit. Apple’s SideCar is still a bit unpredictable, and for changing the slides or the little drawing on the slides I did, a mouse would have been enough.
  • Having my daughter as audience helps, until I have trained myself to look constantly into the camera. Taping a picture of her or another family member to the camera would probably work almost as well, with practice. (She has heard all my stories before…)
  • When recording with a smartphone, put it in flight mode so you don’t get phone calls while recording (as I did.) Incidentally, there are apps out there that allow you to use the iPhone as a camera connected to the PC with a cable, but I have not tested them. It is easy to transfer the video with AirPlay, anyway.
  • The sound is recorded in two microphones (the iPhone and a Røde wireless mic.) I found that it got “fatter” if I used both the tracks, so I did that, but it does sometime screw up the preview function in Camtasia (though not the finished product). That would also have captured both my voice and my daughter’s (though she did not ask any questions during the recording, except on the outtakes.)
  • One great aspect of recording a video is that you can fix errors – just pause and repeat whatever you were going to say, and the cut it in editing. I also used video overlays to correct errors in some slides, and annotations to correct when I said anything wrong (such as repeatedly saying “functional deepening” instead of “structural deepening”.) It does take, time, however…

My excellent colleague Ragnvald Sannes pointed out that this is indicative of how teaching will work in the future, from a work (and remuneration) perspective. We will spend much more time making the content, and less time giving it. This, at the very least, means that teachers can no longer be paid based on the number of hours spent teaching – or that we need to redefine what teaching means…

Moving your course online: Five things to consider

Another video on moving to video-based teaching, this time about some things to consider to make the transition as easy for yourself as possible (as well as increasing the experience for the students):

From the Youtube posting:

Many teachers now have to move their courses online, and are worried about it. Teaching online is different from teaching in a classroom, but not so different: The main thing is still that you know your material and care about the the people at the other end. There are some things to consider, however, so here are five tips to think about when you move your course online:

  1. Talk to one student, not many.
  2. Structure, structure, structure (much more important in online teaching).
  3. Interaction is possible, but needs to be planned.
  4. Bring a friend: Teach with a colleague, for mutual help and a better experience.
  5. Use the recording as a tool for making your teaching better, by reviewing it and editing it yourself.

Five tips for better video teaching

In these viral times, a lot of universities will need to switch to video teaching, and for many teachers, this is a new experience. Here is a short (and fast) video I made with five – non-technical – tips for better video conferencing and teaching.

To sum it up:

1. Sound is more important than picture.
2. Look into the camera!
3. Don’t make the obvious mistakes: Background, lighting, and clothing.
4. Be lively! The medium consumes energy, you need to compensate.
5. Get to know the tools.

Good luck!

Teaching case teaching

IMG_5933For the past two days I have run a seminar on case teaching for faculty at the University of Stavanger Business School, by initiative and invitation from Ken Wathne. (The picture above was taken at 11pm, which tells you something about summer in Norway and the gardening at UiS.)

I love case teaching (obviously) and think it is not only a very useful tool to use and skill to have – but also a way for business schools to future-proof their business model. In a time of Youtube and learning-on-demand, case teaching offers a way to analyse and learn real leadership skills in complex decision situation – something that cannot easily be automated, like standard business courses.

Here are some links to things I have used in the seminar:

  • A useful article on what case teaching is (because many people get this wrong). [My comments on this one is in Norwegian, but by all means read the original]: Garvin, David (2003): “Making the case“, Harvard Magazine.
  • A useful article: Christensen, Clayton C. and Michael Raynor (2003) “Why hard-nosed executives should care about management theory”, Harvard Business Review. Well-written article on how to create theory – and why it is important to understand what works in some contexts does not work in others. I use this article as a rationale for using case teaching to test theory (simulated) practice – case teaching is simulation of decision situations, and is great for finding out if theories are theories or mere beliefs and buzzwords.
  • Case sources: I primarily use the Harvard Business Press case collection. Anyone teaching at a degree-granting institutions has access (you will have to register with an email address belonging to an institution and be able to point to an affiliation, such as a personal web page at the institution.) There are other case sources too – here is a list.
  • Material for students on how to prepare. I like Bill Ellet’s Case Study Handbook, but it can be a bit much for smaller courses or if you use cases only sparingly. HBSP allows you to buy just some its chapters, so that is an alternative. With my colleague Hanno Roberts, I have made a video series for students, originally for BIs MBA program with Fudan University in Shanghai. The videos are a bit long and rambling, but you can always make your own. For complicated cases I have a note on how to analyze complex case using a structured time line.
  • A blog post on how to do effective student feedback.
  • Course design: You can find many examples on the Interwebs, so I steal with pride. Here are some of my own: GRA6834 Business Development and Innovation Management (M.Sc., one semester, weekly sessions), GRA68175 Technology Management and Disruptive Technology (two day module, EMBA), and my memo to students for my course Strategic Technology and Information Management in Shanghai (four day module, more structured and instrumental than a usual case course.)
  • Writing cases: A blog post on how to write a teaching case. You can, of course, use anything – articles, blog posts, videos – as a basis for discussion. Most important is that there is room for real discussion – that there is enough detail, that the material illustrates what you want to get across in a way that is not obvious and allows for interpretations and complexity.

Teaching with cases online

teaching_with_case_onlineCase teaching is not just for the classroom – increasingly, you can (and some schools do) offer discussion-based (or, at least, interaction-courses online.) My buddy Bill Schiano and I wrote a long note on how to do this for Harvard Business Publishing back in 2017 – and I then completely forgot about it.

Recently, I rediscovered it online, published by HBP – so, here goes: Schiano, Bill and Espen Andersen (2017): Teaching with Cases Online, Harvard Business Publishing. Enjoy. (More resources available at the HBP Teaching Center page.)

Incidentally – should you (as a school) consider doing courses this way, beware that this is not a cost reduction strategy. You probably will need to pay the online teachers more than those doing regular classrooms, simply because it is more work and quite a bit more design, at least in the beginning. But it may be an excellent way of reaching student groups you otherwise could not reach, for geographical or timing reasons.

How to write a teaching case

Since I sometimes give classes on how to do case teaching and have written a book on the subject with Bill Schiano, I am sometimes asked how to write a teaching case. The following blog post is a quick tips & tricks collection (essentially an update of this post.)

Why are you writing this case?
First and foremost: Cases are written for a teaching purpose – and to write a teaching case, you need to have a teaching objective in mind. It is not enough to have an interesting company. Even the best company story needs to have a pedagogical point, a theory or dilemma to illustrate. So don’t write a teaching case just because you happen to know someone in a really interesting company – it does need to be a good story, but it also need to have a purpose.

The standard outline
Cases – particularly the standard HBS case – follow an outline that can seem rather trite, but which is very effective. It is something like this:

  • 0.5 page: Intro: The protagonist is introduced, typically pondering a question of some importance. The idea is to tell the students from which perspective the case is written, to set the scene – and that is all there is to it.
  • 1 – 1.5 pages: Description of the company – not the whole history, but the relevant details, explaining what the company is doing, how they make their money. Most companies are to a very large degree formed by their history, so the relevant parts need to be told.
  • 1 page: Industry. Companies exist within a context, and you need to set it. Explain the industry, its evolution, and the company’s position within it. Do it succinctly, but leave more detail in than what is strictly necessary.
  • 1 – 5 pages: Specific issue. This is the meat of the case, the issue at hand, the story to ponder. Make sure you tell it logically and cooly, not leaving anything out, but also conveying the complexity of the situation.
  • 0.5 page: Conclusion, typically with the protagonist wondering what to do, often with some sort of event (board meeting, etc.) where he or she has to present a solution to the problem.

Most cases are just that – one case. You can have a B case and even a C case, but keep them short, since they have to be handed out and read in class. The B case should explain what the company did and perhaps introduce a new problem, the C case, if necessary, should bring some sort of closure, explaining what eventually happened. In my experience, it is very hard to get discussion after a C case – the students become exhausted. As a novice case writer, especially if you are writing about a company with a long history, it can be tempting to create a long string of small cases, but in practice this seldom works well – for one thing, it forces the discussion into a very predictable path.

The no-nos
No theory. A good case should be a description of an interesting situation, frequently a decision point – and nothing else. This means that there should be no theory and no discussion of the case in the case itself – so do not characterise an innovation as disruptive or say that something is an example of an agency problem (unless it is said by one of the protagonists). Save that for the teaching note, or write a separate academic article about it. Not only does this make the case more realistic, it also means it can be used for more purposes than the one initially envisioned. This can be quite challenging for the traditional academic writer – but it is actually good practice to only present the facts (though, of course, which facts you choose to present constitute a discussion of sorts).

No hero, no villain. When teaching students how to analyze a case, I always start by saying that for most business situations, if is useful to begin the analysis with the assumption that people are not stupid and not evil. Consequently, when you write a case, make sure it has no heroes and no villains. If a case has a clear-cut hero or villain, it is a sign that you have not done enough research. Write things so that the students can see the issue from many perspectives.

No judgement. I frequently find, when reading prospective teaching cases – especially if written with the help of a communications department – that judgements tend to be embedded in the text itself, though it is supposed to be as neutral and purely descriptive as possible. So, do not write that a company is “leading”. Instead, describe what they do, perhaps adding a bit of industry numbers for comparison. Let the decision about how leading the company is be up to the student. For example, do not write “Smith was a highly accomplished manager, leading a successful technology implementation.” Instead, write “Smith, at 29, was promoted to be the youngest vice president in company history after conceiving and overseeing the introduction of the first machine learning platform in the industry.”

No consultingese. Be very careful of weasel terms – is the company embarking on a strategic alliance or merely collaborating with another company for a specific purpose? (As a friend of mine said: “I buy all my socks at Marks and Spencer. That does not mean I have a strategic alliance with them.”) Avoid terms that are not well defined, and be precise in your language. Remember, a teaching case has the longest legs when it describes a human situation (since humans change slowly) – so do not not tie the narrative to specifically to a technology. (See the example of Fabritek below.) That being said, I quite often use old technology cases. If the students complain, ask them to take out a pen and change the dates mentioned to last year, update the technology capabilities accordingly – and see if anything else changes.

Dramatic structure
A really well written case has dramatic structure – there is a beginning, a middle that builds up the story, and a really compelling issue at the end. The best cases are almost like detective stories, where you have to dig deep into the analysis to find surprising and sometimes counter-intuitive conclusions. One example of a “detective story” case is Fabritek 1992*, a very old (first published 1969, rewritten by Jan Hammond) case about a quality control issue in a small mechanical workshop. (Hat tip to Robert D. Austin, eminent case teacher, for making me aware of this case and showing me how to teach it.) The case is excellent because it starts with the company (strategic level), proceeds to describe a new situation and a new process (organizational or business logic level) and then introduces the problem (operational level.) Analyzing the operational details leads to one conclusion, which then can be discussed in terms of the organization and its business logic, which can then be placed into a strategic context. The case is excellent because it allows links between these levels – and also teaches the students that the devil indeed resides in the details, and that you as a manager better be very close to how the business you are leading works and makes money.

iPremier-front-pageA second case which shows quality and innovation is iPremier, written by Robert D. Austin and Jeremy C. Short, the first and only graphic novel (cartoon) case I am aware of. The story is about a small online gift company being attacked by hackers, exposing glaring gaps in their security procedures and forcing managers at various levels to make some really hard decisions. The graphic format is excellent in making the various characters real (though they, on average, tend to be way too good-looking for a normal business situation), illustrates technical issues in a way that is very understandable even by non-technology students, and has a cracking good storyline with a B and a C case. I like to introduce a few technical cases in my courses because, well, I don’t think there is enough technology in business schools, and this cases answers very well because it illustrates that certain technical decisions very much require top management attention – ignore (or mindlessly delegate) technology understanding and responsibility at your peril. The graphic format also provides a welcome break from the standard case verbiage, which can be a trifle dour on occasion.

Details, details, details!
Research cases – the kind that is published in refereed journals – tend to be written from a very specific viewpoint, and only facts pertaining to that perspective is included, often in a very abstract format. A teaching case is the direct opposite: It needs lots of details, frequently made available as exhibits (graphs, pictures, documents, tables, etc.) placed at the end, after the main text. A teaching case writer, when visiting a company to write about it, needs to notice the small details, much like a really good journalist does. I tell my students that they should prepare each case so well that they feel like they have worked in the case company – and to allow them to do that, you need to provide the operational details necessary. (Incidentally, having more details than strictly necessary has the added benefit of making the case realistic – in the real world, you have to decide what is important and what is not.)

Doing it – and reading about it.
grandongillI am not aware of many books about how to write a good teaching case, with one exception: Grandon Gill (pictured), professor at University of South Florida and an excellent case teacher, has written a book called Informing with the case method, which is available for free download in PDF, MOBI and EPUB format from his web site. It has lots of details, tips and tricks, not just about case writing, but also about case teaching and course planning. (For the latter, of course, I am duty bound to recommend Bill Schiano’s and my book Teaching with Cases: A Practical Guide.)

Last but definitely not least: Don’t underestimate how much work writing a proper business case is. Getting the details right, describing the dramatis personae, and making the storyline compelling is quite a challenge, in many dimensions different from the traditional academic article. On the other hand, should you get it right, you will have a very effective teaching tool for many years to come.

Good luck!

Case teaching in Vienna

quantI have been asked to give a keynote speech at a conference on case teaching in Vienna, at the The University of Applied Sciences BFI. This is quite an honor, and I am very much looking forward to it.

Should you happen to want to be in Vienna and focus on case teaching on May 19 – well, I hope to see you there!

Effective student feedback

In our book Teaching with cases: A practical guide, Bill Schiano and I talk at a fairly high level about how to give effective student feedback by using a spreadsheet and personalized emails. Our argument is that by giving every student individual feedback in addition to the grade, you reduce the number of grade justification requests and complaints. This blog post is a detailed guide on how to do it – too detailed for the technically inclined, probably, but we all have to start somewhere.

You probably already have all the tools you need on your computer – a spreadsheet and an email client that works with your spreadsheet – such as Excel and Outlook, for example. (For myself, I use Excel and SerialMailer, a cheap serial mail client for Mac.) You can probably use online software as well, for instance a Google spreadsheet (which is nice because editing by more than one teacher is easy) and Gmail, though I have never tried it.

The idea is to use the spreadsheet to organize all your feedback, and to set it up so you use as little time as possible to give as much feedback as possible. I will demonstrate this, with an example for a fictitious course with three in-class sessions (with participation grading, 40% of grade), an individual written examination (30% of grade), and a group assignment (30%). I will show the various details of building the spreadsheet below – if you want to skip ahead and inspect the thing your self, I have made it available for downloading.

I start with a spreadsheet of students and email addresses, provided to me by the administration or downloaded from our LMS. Let’s say it looks something like this:

1eval

(If I have the time or can get the administration to create it from their databases, I ask to have first and last names in separate columns. For this demonstration, I won’t bother.)

Then I add columns for each of the assignments that I am going to grade:

2eval

(In this example, the individual examination has six questions, of which the students should answer four.)

For the group project, I create a separate sheet (in the same workbook, called “Groups”

3eval

The group sheet is exceptionally simple, just group number, points and comment. If you have several group assignments, this is where you will put them:

4eval

Note that I also create a group numbered 0. This is what I use for students who drop the course or don’t do the group assignment.

With that done, I assign students to groups in the Students sheet…

5eval.jpg

…and then I am ready to start teaching my course.

As the course rolls along, I enter points and comments for each student. As mentioned in the book, it is extremely important that you do the participation evaluation immediately after each class. I tend to give the students a score of 1-3, sometimes 1-6, with some definition. As I will show later, what scale you use does not really matter, as you can normalize them to whatever you want later in the process.

Anyway, assume the course is finished, and you have entered comments and points for everything – for the individual student, in the Student sheet….

7eval.jpg

…for the groups, in the Groups sheet:

6eval

To finish the evaluation part (we’ll get to communication later), you need to a) match the group points and comments to each individual student, b) calculate a final score for each student, and c) determine the letter grade for each student.

First: Group grades and comments. For a small class like this, this is probably a bit of overkill – you could just copy comments and points over to each individual student. But doing it the way I show here has the advantage (aside from being correct from a database administrator’s point of view) of error-correction (any error you make will be systematic and therefore easily spotted) and repeatable (the first time you do this, it is a chore, the second time, you just copy your previous spreadsheet and fiddle with it). Moreover, if you have a class with more than 40 students, a bit of “programming” saves time and effort. (I have done this for classes of 350 students, a situation where participation grading is not really possible – except as a small reward for exceptional students – but where the group feedback mechanism becomes extremely valuable.)

So, first – link individual students with their group’s scores and comments, using the LOOKUP function:

8eval

The formula is

           =LOOKUP($E2;Groups!$A$2:$A$8;Groups!B$2:B$8)

and what it does is take the student’s group number (E2), look it up the first column of the “Groups” sheet (Groups!$A$2:$A$8), using fixed references to be able to copy the formula to the rest of the sheet, and displaying the group score (which is in column Groups!$B2:$B8). This nicely picks up all the group scores and comments:

9eval

We now have all the information for each student, then we have to calculate the various scores. We have the exam score already (the average of the exam points) and the participation score (a sum of the score for each session.) We now need to calculate the total points, which isn’t too hard: The max for participation is 9, for the others it is 10, so the formula for the total will be:

01eval

         =(W2*0,3)+(O2*0,3)+(J2*0,4*10/9)

(I use comma as a decimal delimiter, parentheses for readability). We can now add a student ranking in the G column (students are always interested in this, so why not tell them?)

02eval

Now we are ready to set the grades. The simple way to do this is to sort the students by their scores (or rank, if you will):

03eval

How you set the letter grades is up to you, of course, but it helps to have the students sorted. I set grades by starting at the top, trying to get a reasonable distribution, and make sure that I don’t use absolutes so that some unlucky student narrowly misses a better grade. Let’s say we end up here:

04eval

Now we are ready to communicate the results to the students. We will do that by writing a letter to them, composed largely of common text (i.e., feedback that is the same to all students), and them use the mail/merge function of word to merge in the individual details from the spreadsheet.

1feed

Example letter using SerialMailer

As said above, I use a product called SerialMailer on my Mac. The concept is simple: You write the letter, link to the spreadsheet, and insert field names into the text. When the letter is sent out (or printed), the field names are substituted for the values for each individual student.

Here is how to do it in Word (if you want to send it out via email, you need to have Outlook as well.):

First, open Word and write the letter:

2feed

(As you can see, I recycle much of my texts…)

Let’s start by replacing “student” in the opening salutation with the student’s name. Then you open the Mailings tab in Word and hit Select recipients from an existing list…

3feed

…and select your spreadsheet:

000ff

I get this message, click OK:

5feed

And open the “Students” sheet (i.e. the individual sheet):

6feed

If you click “Insert Merge Field” now, you should get a list of the column headings in the spreadsheet:

7feed

Delete the word “student”, choose “Insert Merge Field” and choose “Name”, and the field code will be in the document:

8feed

If you hit “Preview Results”, the code will be replaced by the content for each student:

9feed

Now write field labels and insert the fields you want to share with the students. I like to add the listing at the end of the letter, but you can do whatever you want:

1ff

Hit Preview, and this is what each student will see:

2ff

And there you go. Now hit “Finish and Mail Merge”, and select whether you want to print the documents on paper (or PDF) or send them out via email (shown).

3ff

You must tell Outlook where the email addresses are in the spreadsheet:

5ff

Then specify a subject and choose HTML Message (if you want formatted text):

6ff

…and, well, this is where I will have to stop, since I do not use Outlook. But trust me, it works well, the students love having individualized feedback, and it really isn’t that much more work than just providing the grade. As an added bonus: If students want a grade justification, you can just tell them that they already have it…

(Corrections and feedback welcome, of course.)

Cases: How to prepare for and learn from them

My versatile and creative colleague Hanno Roberts and I have made a series of five videos on case learning and preparation, originally for students at the BI/Fudan MBA program. This teaching method is difficult both for teacher and student, but highly rewarding provided you give it proper attention – which means effective preparation. Hanno and I talk about the goal of case teaching, how students can prepare individually, how to prepare as a group, how to go through the case discussion in the classroom, and then we sum up with some strategies for how to retain what you have learned.

Hanno and I did these videos against a green-screen, with little preparation – we basically met, outlined a structure with some keywords, decided broadly on who should say what, and dove right into it. Most of the videos were shot once, and then the very capable Milosz Tuszko edited them, added background, logos and keywords.

The updated videos are a less wooden than the previous version, methinks, and available in high resolution and with better sound. We clarified the differences between my version of case teaching and Hanno’s (both work, by the way). Over the years the original videos have been much watched – hopefully, our students (and others) will watch them carefully, and the result will be better case teaching, more learning, and an even more enjoyable experience teaching.

Details about each video below the fold…

Continue reading →

How to write a teaching case

(An updated version of this post is available here.)

Some time ago, I was asked to explain what it takes to write a teaching case, so heere is my (very rough and off the cuff) opinion about what it takes (in reality, how a teaching case differs from a research case).

Why are you writing this case?
Cases are written for a teaching purpose – and to write a teaching case, you need to have a teaching objective in mind. It is not enough to have an interesting company. Even the best company story needs to have a pedagogical point, a theory or dilemma to illustrate. So don’t write a teaching case just because you happen to know someone in a really interesting company – it does need to be a good story, but it also need to have a purpose.

The standard outline
Cases – particularly the standard HBS case – follow an outline that can seem rather trite, but which is very effective. It is something like this:

  • 0.5 page: Intro: The protagonist is introduced, typically pondering a question of some importance. The idea is to tell the students from which perspective the case is written, to set the scene – and that is all there is to it.
  • 1 – 1.5 pages: Description of the company – not the whole history, but the relevant details, explaining what the company is doing, how they make their money. Most companies are to a very large degree formed by their history, so the relevant parts need to be told.
  • 1 page: Industry. Companies exist within a context, and you need to set it. Explain the industry, its evolution, and the company’s position within it. Do it succinctly, but leave more detail in than what is strictly necessary.
  • 1 – 5 pages: Specific issue. This is the meat of the case, the issue at hand, the story to ponder. Make sure you tell it logically and cooly, not leaving anything out, but also conveying the complexity of the situation.
  • 0.5 page: Conclusion, typically with the protagonist wondering what to do, often with some sort of event (board meeting, etc.) where he or she has to present a solution to the problem.

Most cases are just that – one case. You can have a B case and even a C case, but keep them short, since they have to be handed out and read in class. The B case should explain what the company did and perhaps introduce a new problem, the C case, if necessary, should bring some sort of closure, explaining what eventually happened. In my experience, it is very hard to get discussion after a C case – the students become exhausted. As a novice case writer, especially if you are writing about a company with a long history, it can be tempting to create a long string of small cases, but in practice this seldom works well – for one thing, it forces the discussion into a very predictable path.

The no-nos
A good case should be a description of an interesting situation, frequently a decision point – and nothing else. This means that there should be no theory and no discussion of the case in the case itself. Save that for the teaching note, or write a separate academic article about it. Not only does this make the case more realistic, it also means it can be used for more purposes than the one initially envisioned. This can be quite challenging for the traditional academic writer – but ist is actually good practice to only present the facts (though, of course, which facts you choose to present constitute a discussion of sorts).

When teaching students how to analyze a case, I always start by saying that for most business situations, if is useful to begin the analysis with the assumption that people are not stupid and not evil. Consequently, when you write a case, make sure it has no heroes and no villains. If a case has a clear-cut hero or villain, it is a sign that you have not done enough research. Write things so that the students can see the issue from many perspectives.

Dramatic structure
A really well written case has dramatic structure – there is a beginning, a middle that builds up the story, and a really compelling issue at the end. The best cases are almost like a detective story, where you have to dig deep into the analysis to find surprising and sometimes counter-intuitive conclusions. One example of a “detective story” case is Fabritek 1992*, a very old (first published 1969, rewritten by Jan Hammond) case about a quality control issue in a small mechanical workshop. (Hat tip to Robert D. Austin, eminent case teacher, for making me aware of this case and showing me how to teach it.) The case is excellent because it starts with the company (strategic level), proceeds to describe a new situation and a new process (organizational or business logic level) and then introduces the problem (operational level.) Analyzing the operational details leads to one conclusions, which can then be discussed in terms the organization and its business logic, which can then be placed into a strategic context. The case is excellent because it allows links between these levels – and also teaches the students that the devil indeed resides in the details, and that you as a manager better be very close to how the business you are leading works and makes money.

iPremier-front-pageA second case which shows quality and innovation is iPremier, written by Robert D. Austin and Jeremy C. Short, the first and only graphic novel (cartoon) case I am aware of. The story is about a small online gift company being attacked by hackers, exposing glaring gaps in their security procedures and forcing managers at various levels to make some really hard decisions. The graphic format is excellent in making the various characters real (though they, on average, tend to be way too good-looking for a normal business situation), illustrates technical issues in a way that is very understandable even by non-technology students, and has a cracking good storyline with a B and a C case. I like to introduce a few technical cases in my courses because, well, I don’t think there is enough technology in business schools, and this cases answers very well because it illustrates that certain technical decisions very much require top management attention – ignore (or mindlessly delegate) technology understanding and responsibility at your peril. The graphic format also provides a welcome break from the standard case verbiage, which can be a trifle dour on occasion.

Details, details, details!
Research cases – the kind that is published in refereed journals – tend to be written from a very specific viewpoint, and only facts pertaining to that perspective is included, often in a very abstract format. A teaching case is the direct opposite: It needs lots of details, frequently made available as exhibits (graphs, pictures, documents, tables, etc.) placed at the end, after the main text. A teaching case writer, when visiting a company to write about it, needs to notice the small details, much like a really good journalist does. I tell my students that they should prepare each case so well that they feel like they have worked in the case company – and to allow them to do that, you need to provide the operational details necessary. (Incidentally, having more details than strictly necessary has the added benefit of making the case realistic – in the real world, you have to decide what is important and what is not.)

Doing it – and reading about it.
grandongillI am not aware of many books about how to write a good teaching case, with one exception: Grandon Gill (pictured), professor at University of South Florida and an excellent case teacher, has written a book called Informing with the case method, which is available for free download in PDF, MOBI and EPUB format from his web site. It has lots of details, tips and tricks, not just about case writing, but also about case teaching and course planning. (For the latter, of course, I am duty bound to recommend Bill Schiano’s and my book Teaching with Cases: A Practical Guide.)

Last but definitely not least: Don’t underestimate how much work writing a proper business case is. Getting the details right, describing the dramatis personae, and making the storyline compelling is quite a challenge, in many dimensions different from the traditional academic article. On the other hand, should you get it right, you will have a very effective teaching tool for many years to come.

Good luck!

Case book update

The case teaching book is, I have been reliably informed, selling well. It is currently in heavy rotation on Harvard Business Publishing’s web pages (see image below) and also available on Amazon.com.)

And that, well, makes my day a little brighter…

hbsp

Teaching with Cases: Detailed table of contents

bookcover2The Table of Contents in the paper and PDF version of Teaching with Cases: A Practical Guide is only at the chapter level. For readers wanting a more detailed overview of the book or to find something specific, here is the detailed table of contents:

Preface  vii
Acknowledgements     ix

Chapter 1: Introduction: Why you should read this book 1
Why case teaching?     2
How case classes and students vary     4
Class size     5
Core versus elective     5
Part-time versus full-time     5
Gender     5
Weekly versus  modular courses     6
Domestic versus international     6
Single versus multi-section     6
Executive versus graduate versus undergraduate     7
One of many case classes for students vs. only or one of few 7
In school versus other location     7
Practical Guidance for all Case-Teaching Faculty     7
The central framework: Foundation, flow, and feedback     8

Chapter 2: Foundations: Preparing for the course     11
Taking Ownership    12
Making a Contract     14
Developing Content     16
Structuring the syllabus     26
Selecting cases     18
Selecting readings and textbooks     24
Using guest speakers     26
Using assignments     28
Working with Students     29
Motivating Students     32
Enthusiasm and Engagement     33
Relevance     33
Opportunities to build valuable skills     33
Safe participation     34
Fun     34
Finding Information about Students’ Backgrounds     35
Helping the students prepare for case discussions    36
Classroom participation requirement     36
Establishing Infrastructure     38
Establishing seating arrangements     39
Using Name cards and seating charts     42
Setting length and frequency of class sessions     44
Session Length  45
Session Frequency  45
Wrapping up     46

Chapter 3: Flow During the Class Session    49
Preparing Yourself    51
Crafting a teaching plan     52
Demeanor in class     54
Dressing for class and impression management     55
Managing your anxiety     57
Preparation     57
Exercises     58
Rituals     59
Starting to Teach     59
The first class     59
Opening classes     62
Building trust in the class     64
Managing the Discussion     66
The Emcee: Calling on students and managing airtime     67
The Scribe: Using the board     70
Board plan     71
Writing on the board     74
The Conductor: Using body language, silence, and movement 76
Using the physical space   79
The TV Host: Asking questions   82
Giving up control     84
Time management     85
How long to let a discussion go     86
If you are running out of time     86
Breaks and other interruptions    87
Teaching long class days     88
Beyond Discussion     89
Using theory and other non-case material     89
Inductive versus deductive case use 90
Communicating Theory  91
Role-Playing     93
Multipart cases     94
Group work     95
Group Presentations     96
Group Discussions    98
Team teaching in the classroom    99
Are you getting the most from each student?     101
Humor in the classroom     102
Energy    103
Raising the energy level     104
Relationships among and with students     106
Concluding a Discussion     107

Chapter 4: Feedback: Assignments, Grading and Guidance 111
The Evaluative Mindset  112
Designing Evaluation   113
Designing assignments 115
Individual Oral Assignments   115
Individual Written Assignments 116
Group Oral Assignments  117
Group Written Assignments  118
Designing Exams     118
Selecting Cases for Exams   118
Writing Exam Questions  119
Take-Home Exams   121
Designing Term Papers  122
Term Papers as Research Method  124
Grading    125
A matter of scaling     125
How to structure feedback     127
Group Work  130
Final Exams  130
Class participation     131
Capturing Participation  133
Setting Expectations  134
Setting Expectations by Self-Evaluation  135
Exams  136
The dreaded extra-credit requests    139
Handling academic dishonesty     140
Conclusion     143

Chapter 5: Managing Classroom Issues     145
Issues with Individual Student    145
How do I manage students who hog airtime?     146
How do I manage combative students?     147
What can I do about students’ computer use in class?    148
What do I do if a student does not pay attention in class?   149
What do I do if a student complains?     150
How do I accommodate students with disabilities?     151
Issues with groups of students     152
What Do I Do When Students Are Not Well Prepared? 152
How do I get students to prepare better?     153
Reward Good Preparation 153
Help Them Along  154
Draw Out Prepared But Reticent Students 154
Require Case Write-ups or Give Pop Quizzes  154
Give a Stern Lecture  154
Make An Example of a Student or Two  154
How do I stop side conversations?     155
How Do I Manage Dysfunctional Class Behavior?  156
Hissing  156
Genuflection   156
Sharking  157
What if the class turns against me?     157
How is Teaching Executives Different?  159
How should I deal with student pranks?     161
How Do I Deal with Student Representatives?    163
How Do I Deal with Dysfunctional Groups? 164
Free-Riders  164
Personality Conflicts   165
Poor Project Management   165
Poor Performance   165
Issues Beyond Students     166
What if I can’t find enough cases that fit?     166
What do I do if I have lost track of the discussion?     167
What if I run out of questions?     168
How do I deal with problems in an intensive-format course? 137
Prepare Differently  169
Manage Expectations  169
Manage Process Closely  169
What can I do if I am low on energy?     170
What If the Administration Gets Involved?

Chapter 6 Quantitative and technical material     174
Flipping the Qualitative and Quantitative    175
Being Qualitative about the Quantitative  175
Being Quantitative about the Qualitative  176
Explicitly Teach Estimation   177
Quantify Anything   177
Know the Industry Data   177
Change Assumptions or Problems on the Fly  179
Teaching Quantitative Material   179
Making a Teaching Plan for a Quantitative Case   179
Pacing the Discussion  180
Asking for a Number at the Beginning   181
Managing Math Phobia and Aversion to Numbers   183
Making the value clear   182
Acknowledging the Phobic  182
Filling in the Holes  182
Fostering a Sense of Self-Efficacy  183
Using the Board  183
Making the best use of students     185
When Students Go Wrong  185
When No One Has the Correct Analysis  186
Discussing a Quantitative Case with Subjective Numbers or Estimates   187
Using Groups  188
Teaching Technical Material   189
Motivating the Study of Technology   189
Structuring the Teaching of Technology  190
Conclusion 192

Chapter 7 Adjusting for language and culture     195
The Foreign Student  197
Making Adjustments for Foreign Students   200
The Foreign Teacher   202
The Teacher Abroad  204
Expectations for teaching   205
Teacher power     206
Student behavior     207
Using Interpreters   208
Trust the locals     211

Chapter 8: Preparing for the next time     213
Debriefing a course     213
Interpreting and using student feedback     215
How to Read Student Feedback   215
Striving for High Evaluations   217
Reviewing Case Selection   217
Debriefing with a Teaching Group 218
Archiving Material   218
Evaluating case teachers, including yourself     219
Before Class  219
During Class  219
After Class  220
Managing relationships with alumni     220

Chapter 9: Fostering Case Teaching at the School Level  223
The Commoditized Business School  223
Relevance is Relevant   224
Integration is Integral   225
Institutionalizing Case Teaching   228
Recruiting, Incentives and Promotion   228
Teaching-Related Procedures   230
Getting Infrastructure Right   230
Classroom Design  231
Good, Abundant Board Space   231
Blackboards Rather Than Whiteboards   231
Seating   232
Making Cases Easy to Use and Produce   233
Case Production   234

Chapter 10 Technologies for Case Teaching  238
Take Control of the Technology  238
Technology for Teacher Productivity  239
Teacher’s Computer Use in Class   241
Presentation Software   243
Tools for Student-Teacher Interaction   246
Learning Management Systems     246
Build a Sandbox   246
Explore the System   247
Maintain Communication Norms   247
Create a FAQ Repository  247
Structure for Reuse  247
Facilitate Searching   247
Consider the User’s Experience   248
Maintain Structure   248
Automate Availability   248
Explore the Analytics   248
Seek and Accept Help  249
Other Technologies to Support Student Interaction  249
Social Media   249
In-Class Polling and Voting Tools   249
Questionnaires   250
Shared Documents   250
Analysis Tools   250
Online Simulations  251
Online Teaching   251
Teleconference Teaching   251
Get the Basic Technology Right 252
Communicate in a Way Suited to the Medium   252
Communicate via Side Channel and Back Channel  253
Get to Know the Students  254
Videoconferencing  254
Lighting and Background   255
Sound   256
The Video Camera   256
Concurrently Teaching Face-to-Face and Remotely   259
Teaching Asynchronously with Discussion Forums   260
Foundations: Designing the Course and Forming the Contract   262
Flow: Running the Discussion   265
Guidelines for Students   267
Feedback: Evaluating and Closing the Loop 269
Managing the inevitable technical failures   271
Conclusion   273

Index   275
About the Authors  293

Case teaching when you are not at Harvard

Our book is out!
bookcover2Bill Schiano and I have written a book, Teaching with Cases: A Practical Guide, officially launched today at Harvard Business Publishing, available as paperback or PDF (304 pages).

Bill and I are both passionate about case teaching and use it whenever possible. We have aimed the book at the kind of people we were 18 years ago: Teachers wanting to use case teaching, but finding ourselves in institutions where case teaching is not the dominant teaching method. (We actually wanted to name the book Case teaching when you are not at Harvard, but saner minds intervened.)

There are a few books on how to do case teaching available, but common to them is that they are a) rather philosophical and abstract in their advice, and b) take the institutional environment for granted – i.e., they assume that you are at a school, such as Harvard Business School, Wharton, INSEAD or University of Western Ontario, where case teaching is the norm, the students are brilliant and fiercely competitive, classrooms are made for case teaching and excellent teaching is valued by the administration (and the promotion committees.)

We wanted the book to be relentlessly practical – what to wear to class, how to deal with disruptive students, how to get students to prepare, how to grade participation. We also wanted the book to address how to create the necessary infrastructure for case teaching with little or no administrative support, down to how you create name cards (let the students do it or use a spreadsheet/mail-merge function) and class chart (take a photo of the students holding their name cards, print it in weak grayscale for after-class note-taking.)

The book is built around three concepts: Foundations (how to set up the course, contract with the students, and set up infrastructure); Flow (how to conduct the discussion in the classroom, manage time and boards, ask questions, and conclude discussions); and Feedback (how to design grading and feedback, especially participation grading.) We have extra chapters on dealing with difficult issues (much of it based on questions from participants in HBS’ case teaching seminars); how to teach quantitative and technical material; how to deal with differences in language and culture (foreign students and foreign teachers); how to prepare for the next course; how to foster case teaching at the school level (many business schools are now looking to better teaching, including case teaching, as a differentiator); and lastly, a long and detailed chapter on technologies for case teaching, including our views on how to teach cases online.

The book also includes a collection of online resources (sample syllabi, sample teaching plans, etc.) for teachers, available at teachingwithcases.hbsp.harvard.edu. We hope to grow this collection as we hear from readers and build more material ourselves.

That’s it for now – I’ll be back with excerpts, a full table of contents, and various other nuggets eventually. But given that this book has been on my mind for a couple of years now, it is a rather good day…

Scandinavian cases: Call for abstracts

With two colleagues, Gerhard Schjelderup and Mikael Lönnborg, I am trying to create a case collection, to be published as a book. We start with a call for abstracts, with a deadline of June 9. You will find the details in this PDF document.

The main idea is simply to do something about the lack of available teaching cases on Scandinavian (or, for that matter, Nordic) companies. We want cases that are like HBS cases – no theory in the case, a thorough description of an interesting company with an interesting problem. Seems simple enough, no?

See you for the workshop on October 10!

Cases: How to prepare for and learn from them

These videos have been updated: You find the new ones here.

My versatile and creative colleague Hanno Roberts and I have made a series of five videos on case learning and preparation, originally for students at the BI/Fudan MBA program. This teaching method is difficult both for teacher and student, but highly rewarding provided you give it proper attention – which means effective preparation. Hanno and I talk about the goal of case teaching, how students can prepare individually, how to prepare as a group, how to go through the case discussion in the classroom, and then we sum up with some strategies for how to retain what you have learned. Hanno and I did these videos against a green-screen, with little preparation – we basically met, outlined a structure with some keywords (displayed on the little computer on the table in front of us, decided broadly on who should say what, and dove right into it. Most of the videos were shot twice, and then the very capable Lars Holand picked the least bad clips, added the background and logos, and generated the files in .mp4 and .flv. The lack of scripting was intentional – we did not want the videos to be too formal and stultifying, though the format itself might be. We also wanted to be a bit formal, to make sure we got our main points across. The results is a bit stiff, there are a few repetitions (we intro each clip, to make them more embeddable), but given that these were created also to be understandable for students whose first language isn’t English, I think it kind of works. And it was fun to do, and not too much work. Anyway, the videos are there, free for all to use – and hopefully, our students will watch them carefully, and the result will be better case teaching, more learning, and an even more enjoyable experience teaching. Continue reading →