Category Archives: The thoughtful manager

How wide and how deep is your platform?

(A lightly edited translation of this Norwegian blogpost, for the benefit of my non-Norwegian students.)

About business development for platforms – and when it goes too far

A few years ago, almost all business development was about moving from selling products or individual services to becoming a partner with the customer. This development was partly driven by the need to create differentiation and connection in a world where standard services were becoming comparable and thus price-sensitive, but also enabled by technology such as CRM systems.

The next step in this evolution – ​​an the chief aim for many companies since the early 2000s – is to try to become a platform: a service that creates value not only based on what customers can use it for, but also by having elements of network effects, so that it gets better the more customers use it. These effects can be direct – customers communicate through your platform, or indirect, in that the knowledge you gain from having many customers on the platform allows you to create services that no one else can.

Starting a platform is difficult, as you have to have something to offer your customers until the platform – preferably the other customers – is big enough or important enough to be an attraction in itself. I usually talk about having a “killer” of some kind – a feature or a group – but the easiest thing is probably to already have a network, which is why large networks like Google or Facebook buy growing networks like YouTube or Instagram.

Well. But assuming you manage to build the beginnings of a platform by setting up something, a platform, that addresses a two-part market – how do you further develop it?

Reach and range

When looking at the value of a platform, there are two dimensions that are central: Reach and range [4] – or breadth and depth, as I like to call it.

The breadth is who you can reach through the platform. It’s about both how many people use it and who the users are. It’s easy to see the number of users as the central goal here, but just as important can be who these users are. Finn.no, for example, has by far the most users in Norway, but if you’re selling used clothes, Tise is the one to go for – they don’t have as many users as Finn, but if you’re selling used fashion clothes, they have all the users that matter.

Depth is about what you can do on the platform: What services are offered. Platforms often start by offering a central service, and then expand to other things over time. Vipps, for example, had payments between private individuals as its only service to begin with, but has gradually added store payments, identification (login) and the ability to photograph bills and pay them.

Developmental problems

Business development for platforms essentially has two dimensions – and one can develop in both breadth and depth: Making the platform attractive to more customers (preferably by finding new customer groups that complement the ones you already have), or adding more and more services so that customers can eventually do everything through the platform. This increases the customers’ dependence on the platform – something that was called stickiness at least in the early days of the Internet .)

Both can be problematic.

Free until further notice

One problem that can arise is that because platforms make money from different things, their pursuit of revenue will lead to them offering for free what others make money from. Take Vipps and Finn, for example: For a period of time, Finn tried to introduce a payment service called SpID (Schibsted Payment ID) that would handle logins and payments for, among others, Aftenposten, Finn.no, VG and several other services. It was never a success, but at least it got Vipps to keep its prices down and invite cooperation with many other providers.

Finn has had greater success observing what other competitors are doing, and then offering the same to its customers, either by developing it itself, or by acquiring or forming alliances with startups that make the Finn platform better.

Companies that have not been successful here include Telenor, which has tried many things to get greater profitability out of its expensive and extensive networks, only to find itself forced back into cost competition for basic traffic. While Telenor had the resources, it could have built up a range of services – alarm systems, health applications, video conferencing, entertainment – ​​but it did not have the appetite for such large investments outside its core business. It had also burned through a number of investments in entertainment, where the fact that Telenor was big in Norway was of no consequence to the big entertainment producers, who negotiate prices for content all over the world. Today, Telenor – like most telecommunications companies – is a shadow of its former self, reduced to delivering basic services from an eighth of its formidable headquarters in Fornebu.

Enshittification

Cory in a quiet moment…

Another problem with platform business development is a phenomenon called (it was actually the word of the year in the US in 2023) enshittification . The term was coined by Cory Doctorow , first in an article in Wired [1], then in an excellent follow-up in the Financial Times [2]. (Cory is, by the way, a Canadian early Internet activist, best-selling author, and brilliant speaker who I (ahem) once knew and hosted when he gave a talk in Oslo .)

In short, enshittification is about platform providers, in an attempt to increase and maintain their profits, luring new user groups by selling the user groups they already have, and then repeating the process when the newest user group has become dependent on the platform.

Or, as Cory puts it :

Here is how platforms die: First, they are good to their users; then they abuse their users to make things better for their business customers; finally, they abuse those business customers to claw back all the value for themselves. Then, they die.

Facebook is a typical example: Initially a place you went to talk to friends and connections, which has now become a hodgepodge of content and ads you don’t want, crowding out what you really want, since it doesn’t pay.

Balance in everything

Marketing is about creating and retaining customers. The problem for platforms is that it is not always clear who the customers are, as they are often faced with two-sided markets [3,5] (seller and buyer, for example) where one side generates most – often all – of the revenue. This can make it difficult, especially in times of recession, to maintain the interests of the customer group that does not generate revenue over time. However, this balance between long-term thinking and short-term profit is nothing new to business development in general – how much quality to put into product and customer service, for example, has always been there as a balance to deal with.

So, by all means, increase the breadth and depth of what you do with your platform, but don’t forget the reason customers came there in the first place – to get a basic function performed, and, to a large extent, to relate to each other.


References:

[1] C. Doctorow, “The ‘Enshittification’ of TikTok,” Wired . Accessed: Oct. 03, 2025. [Online]. Available: https://www.wired.com/story/tiktok-platforms-cory-doctorow/

[2] C. Doctorow, “’Enshittification’ is coming for absolutely everything,” Financial Times , Feb. 08, 2024. Accessed: Oct. 03, 2025. [Online]. Available: https://www.ft.com/content/6fb1602d-a08b-4a8c-bac0-047b7d64aba5

[3] T. Eisenmann, G. Parker, and MWV Alstyne, “ Strategies for two-sided markets ,” Harvard Business Review , vol. 84, no. 10, pp. 92–101, 2006.

[4] Ø. Fjeldstad and E. Andersen, ” Casting off the chains: Value shops and value networks ,” European Business Forum , no. 14, pp. 47–53, Summer 2003.

[5] G. Parker and M. Van Alstyne, “Two-Sided Network Effects: A Theory of Information Product Design,” Management Science , vol. 10, pp. 1494–1504, 2005.

What should higher education do about AI?

Herewith, a video and transcript of my inaugural lecture, on November 4th.

Chasing Scarcity in Teaching: Business Education in a Time of AI Disruption

Inaugural lecture of Teaching Professor Espen Andersen, BI Norwegian Business School, 4 November 2026

Lightly edited transcript:

Well, hi everyone. I’m not usually nervous when I teach, but I am now. Thank you all for coming. I was actually made a teaching professor a year and a half ago, but I got sick, so the whole thing got delayed. But thanks to all of you for coming here – family, friends, colleagues, former colleagues, members of Comunita, and members of my former class here at BI. We’re having a party this Friday, so I’m looking forward to that.

What I’m going to talk about is this notion of AI – what it is and how it affects teaching. And I’ll start by telling a story, which I tend to tell in all my courses as a sort of final story.

The best essay on innovation I have ever read was written by Elting Morison and published in 1950 – I think it was written some years before. It’s called “Gunfire at Sea”, and it is the story of a captain on a US Navy ship who made certain modifications to how they fired the guns and improved the accuracy from 8% to 74%. Which I think you’ll agree is pretty good. It took 30 years before the Navy adopted his innovations, and there were many reasons for that.

At the beginning of the essay, Morison tells this story about the guns. In the summer of 1940, France had fallen, Britain was basically fighting Germany on its own, and the danger of Hitler coming across the Channel was imminent. At the same time, Britain didn’t have weapons, because most of its heavy machinery and heavy weapons had been lost in France before the evacuation at Dunkirk. So they had to do something. And they had all these old guns, which looked like this – they’re called howitzers. So they pulled them out of storage, hitched them up to trucks, drove them down to the coast and pointed them towards the English Channel.

And then they said, “Wait a second, maybe we can improve the rate of fire using modern methods.” Now, modern methods at that time meant something called time and motion studies. You use film and a stopwatch, and you try to take away unnecessary movement. So they set up a gun, with eight men to man it and a sergeant to command. They followed the routines, fired the gun, and filmed it. Then they sat down and started to analyse the film.

And then the scientists saw something very weird. Right before the gun was fired – about three seconds before – two of the soldiers stood to attention, like that. And they stood to attention until the gun was fired, and a little while after. In terms of firing a gun as rapidly as possible, that is a fantastic waste of manpower.

So they thought, okay, we have to do something about that – but we are not going to change anything until we know why it is there. So they went to the sergeant, and he said, “Well, it’s procedure.” They followed the chain of command up, and finally they got to this old colonel. He should have been pensioned off a long time ago, but there’s a war on. He had actually been in the Boer War and in the First World War, when these guns had been used. So they dragged him in, plunked him down in front of the film projector, showed him the movie and said, “What’s going on here?” He looked at the movie and said, “Run the movie again.” He looked at it again and said, “I’ve got it. They’re holding the horses.”

But there aren’t any horses! And you can imagine: what are we going to do with those two soldiers for those seconds? Well, there are no horses to hold, so they’ll just stand there like this. Rather than changing what we do, we just continue to do what we’re doing and adapt it a little bit. Remember that story. I’m going to come back to it.

I’m going to talk a little bit about theory – very little theory. In fact, it’s not even theory. This is my framework. I made this, and I haven’t published it anywhere – maybe I should. But this is what I teach my students, and it goes like this: Technology changes the business environment. In fact, changes in technology are the primary change agent when businesses change. And when the business environment changes, we have to change our strategy. And I tell my students and executives, and anybody who wants to hear: wouldn’t it be nice to understand how technology changes, so that we can change our strategy before we’re forced to by the environment? That’s why I teach technology.

The trouble is, we don’t really know how technology influences organizations. When I came back from doing my doctorate and working in the States in 1996, I got into a debate about the productivity of information technology. Just as we now have the idea of AI and productivity – we see AI everywhere, everybody’s talking about how fantastic it is, but do we see any change in the productivity numbers? No. We had precisely the same debate over PCs back in ’96.

I got into a discussion with a researcher in Norway who had written in Aftenposten that there was no point in buying PCs, because he had timed how fast you wrote on a typewriter versus on a PC, and the difference was 10%, so the PC was not worth it. I wrote back and said: “I’m actually sitting on an airplane with my portable computer, typing this answer, and you’re absolutely correct – I can’t type much faster. But when I’m done, I can email this to Aftenposten and they can take it straight in.” Meaning that the productivity impact shows up in other places than where you measure it.

However, Aftenposten had something called typographers, and they had a union, and the union demanded that everything that came in electronically had to be retyped. So Aftenposten didn’t get the productivity benefit until they got rid of the typographers. Which teaches us that productivity shows up somewhere else in the whole supply chain, and you have to change your organization in order to reap the benefits.

Okay, that was the theory. Let’s talk about the technology that is changing things, and that technology is artificial intelligence. Trying to define artificial intelligence is more of a philosophy question than anything else. But I tend to divide it into three things – or most people do. We talk about analytical AI, generative AI and agentic AI. Analytical AI is sometimes called machine learning – think of it as the Excel department. Generative AI is the Word department, or the picture department. And agentic AI, where you have electronic agents doing something on your behalf, is perhaps the Teams department.

All of these are disruptive innovations in their own right. The main thing about a disruptive innovation is that the existing players in an industry are the least adaptive to the new technology.

So if you look at analytical AI, it challenges the traditional scientific method. In the traditional scientific method, Popper and other philosophers of science would say you have a theory, and from the theory you develop testable hypotheses. Then you collect the data and test the model, and maybe you validate it – but very often we don’t. Now, machine learning works like this: You have some data. You take 20% of the data and put it over here. Then you take the remaining 80% and tell the machine to find a model. And once it has found a model, you point it at the data it hasn’t seen yet and test how well it does. Can it predict whether there is cancer in this lesion? Can it predict how much this customer will buy? Can it predict how much we should pay for an ad on Google? The validation happens out of sample.

And once we have a model developed, we don’t have a theory. The reason we don’t have a theory is that, especially if you use neural networks, the model is so complicated that it’s humanly impossible to explain how it derives its decisions. And this is a challenge, because the skills that were good here – theory formation and so on – are not that good here.

How about generative AI? That’s what people mean when they talk about AI – ChatGPT and friends. There are many ways to think about it, but the way I look at it, it is a way of predicting the next word in a sentence, and a way of constructing something according to what is called a reward function. And the reward function tends to be what you’re happy with. I had a prospective doctoral student who told me that she was thinking of applying to BI because her AI therapist had told her to. And the AI therapist obviously tells her whatever she wants to hear.

I refer to it as hyper-efficient mediocrity, because AI can only do that which has been done before. It can do it very efficiently, and you can have an army of agents that do it for you, but it can’t come up with something that is genuinely new. So rather than try to explain it myself, I decided to just ask: what is hyper-efficient mediocrity? And it says that generative AI creates hyper-efficient mediocrity by automating routine white-collar tasks, such as answering basic questions, summarizing text and generating standard documentation of all kinds. And it’s very good at that. Where did it find that? Well, I wrote an article about it. And rather than summarize it myself, I just asked Google, and it summarized it for me. That’s what generative AI is good for. It does the simple work, leaving us to do the really valuable, really creative, really judgmental work. But it does it very well – and better and better.

One of the things it does is automate the simple work, and we’re now beginning to see that in the productivity numbers. This came from Erik Brynjolfsson at Stanford last week, I think, saying that if you now look at industries that are exposed to AI, we see lower hiring in the lower age brackets. Because the routine work normally done by younger people is increasingly being automated.

That challenges us, because it challenges the educational trajectory. Education used to look like this: We have the basics – you go to school. Then we have the specifics – you go to higher education. And once you come out of higher education, you have the tools and the theoretical knowledge, but you don’t yet have enough skill to apply it. That you have to learn as a junior person in a company. I’d say 95% of my students start in consulting, and they start at the lower level, doing very routine, hard work. And through doing so, they learn the skills that allow them to get more responsibility, experience and judgment.

Well, now we have a problem, because now we have AI and YouTube. I think it was ten years ago that I heard one of the people in the top management group say he had overheard students behind him on the subway saying, “I don’t go to classes. I just go to YouTube.” When I want to learn something new, like how a language model works, I go to YouTube. That’s what we’re competing against. And then we have AI, where students can now produce beautiful reports very, very quickly.

So you get the basics from school – but increasingly we see students dropping out of school. My wife Kristine is a real expert on people leaving school. (My clock talks to me.) It’s very complicated, but it seems that fewer and fewer people can deal with it. The specifics, higher education – well, increasingly online, and increasingly students are not getting the education they need, because they basically ask AI to do it. And now they can no longer get jobs. So where are they going to get the professional skills? Where is the next generation of experience and judgment going to come from?

There’s a little hint of an answer here: I think we need to move this training into what we do. There are two reasons for that. One is that these young people need to be educated to perform at a higher level when they come out, because companies can no longer afford that training period. But also, we need something more to do, because we’re being outcompeted by YouTube and AI and all that stuff. So we need to make what we do more real.

And then the last one: agentic AI, which does things on your behalf. What does that mean? We sort of divide AI into augmenting what you do – helping you get better – and that’s what most of us do. Most people here have grey hair; that’s what we do. But you can also use AI to replace people. Rather than hiring humans, we hire digital employees who go out and do things for us, and more and more people do that. And this could be the situation: “I’ll have my people talk to your people.” Well, they’re down here – some of them are human, some of them are digital.

By the way, this is a New Yorker cartoon, right? No, it’s not. I asked Gemini to make it. I specified it to Gemini. The signature you see down here is a mix of three or four artists who draw for The New Yorker. I should have put my own signature on it, but it didn’t feel right. That’s pretty good. I specified the joke, but it made the drawing.

How do you know that something is an agent? How do you know that you’re talking to a human? I’ve had that experience now – people calling me, and I have to figure out: are they real, or is this a fake? You’ve probably had that too. That was the woman I interviewed, because I thought she was fake. Turned out she was real – except she talked to her agent.

Now, we can have some sort of tests. Everybody has pressed this one: you click on it, and it figures out you are not a robot. It does that by analysing the way you move the mouse, because we cannot move it as precisely as a machine can. But sometimes you meet somebody… This is a friend of mine on Facebook. Her name is Tina Underhill. She lives on a farm in Suldal, in Rogaland. She works for a small software company called Aadnøy Labs, where she does all the accounting and things like that. She sometimes puts out pictures – when they have new lambs on the farm, or when she goes for a walk in the mountains. She’s not real.

She’s made by Alf Aadnøy. Alf is a member of the network of managers that I run with Haakon Gellein. He has programmed her and named her – his farm is named Underbakke, so she’s named Underhill. She does a lot of work for him, answers calls and does boring things like that. And he says that if he were making her all over again, he wouldn’t have made her so attractive, because he has to fend off a lot of not very welcome attention.

This is important for many companies. I’m not going to go into it – it’s not part of this – but a lot of competitive advantage online has been due to what we call network effects: consumer platforms. Take Finn, which has a 95% market share, and they get really antsy if their EBIT is below 40%. Then there’s a crisis in the house. I wish I was that lucky. Now they have a problem. We go to Finn because they have a 95% market share: if we want to sell something, that’s where the buyers are, and if we want to buy something, that’s where the sellers are. And we don’t bother with the smaller platforms. But if I have an agent that goes out and visits for me, I could go to Finn, I could go to Golsfjellet kjøp og salg, I could go to Facebook Marketplace – I could go anywhere, because the agent has infinite time and can just go out there. And that erodes something we thought was pretty permanent in the competitive world of the internet: network externalities.

So that’s that part: the impact on higher education.

That’s sort of the title of this whole thing: scarcity in teaching. What does that mean? Well, you can’t make money – money above normal profits – selling something that is available in abundance. You have to sell something that’s scarce. And AI can’t do creativity and judgment. It can’t come up with things that are truly new – yet. It can, through a process of self-complication, but it’s hard for it to come up with new things, and it’s very hard for it to exercise judgment. So we have to teach that. That’s a scarce skill we need to teach. How do we do that? That’s not easy.

The way I see it, it’s not easy because it requires a few things. It requires not just teaching students, but challenging them in an environment that is a simulation of what they’re going to meet after they’re done. It requires unpredictability. It requires that we don’t tell them what they’re going to learn, we don’t tell them how they’re going to do their exam, and we don’t tell them how they got their grade. Jan Ketil Arnulf has written an article called “Without unpredictability, higher education dies”. So we have to be unpredictable. And it requires making the classroom a place where the students and the instructor want to be – which I also stole from Jan Ketil.

So how do we do that? Well, I can only talk about what I do, because that’s my experience. But I have had students engaged. I have students who show up. I have students who take my courses. I don’t have drop-off in who comes to class. Quite a few of my colleagues do this as well, but they have different techniques. I can only talk about what I do.

And I prioritize having fun. That does not mean that the students have fun in the classroom – actually, they’re quite nervous. But I have fun. There are a couple of things we need to rethink. Students are product, not customers. Students come to me and say, I would like to do this by myself, I would like to do that. I had a student who came to me and said, “I have to leave early every Monday. Will that hit my participation grade?” I said, “Yes.” And he said, “But I have to go to work. I’m a professional football player.” I said, “No, you misunderstand. Every Monday, you will be 45 minutes late for practice.” And he said, “Can you speak to my trainer?” And I said, “No, I’m not your father. You do it yourself.” He actually showed up, and he became my teaching assistant the next year. Students respond to challenges, and we have to challenge them.

The second thing we need to think about is that BI is a health club, not a tanning salon. I’ve stolen that one from Øyvind Revang, who used to teach here. Students think we’re going to come in and sit down and sit like this, and then we’re going to get a nice tan and a diploma that shows we have a tan, and then we can go. That’s not how it works. BI is a place where you can train and practise and get better, and it’s going to be painful and require something.

For a long time I have wanted to write an article called “What can higher education learn from Kompani Lauritzen?” For those who are not Norwegian, this is a TV programme where they take civilians in. It’s a reality show where they put them through a boot camp, and they meet this guy – I’ve forgotten his name, but he’s known in Norway as Fenriken. That’s with a capital F; it means the second lieutenant. He comes in and tells the people who are there what they’re going to do, how they’re going to do it, what the limits are, and what is considered acceptable and unacceptable behaviour and performance. He does it in a supportive but firm way, and he says wonderful things. My favourite one is this: people complain, “But I did wash my room,” and he says, “We’re not looking for the activity of washing. We’re looking for the result: clean.” I think we can learn a lot from Kompani Lauritzen.

I know one guy who has this attitude – my colleague Hanno Roberts. He is frequently voted the best professor in our Chinese programmes and others. When he comes in, he has a T-shirt on, and on the T-shirt it says “No pain, no gain”. That’s the right attitude, and that’s what we need to do, I think – or at least it has worked for me.

So how do we do that? Well, you basically have to force students. You have to force them to participate. You have to force them to prepare. I have something called prepared presence. In my courses you have to show up for 70% of the classes in order to qualify, but it is a prepared presence. So I can say, “Birgitte, please introduce this case for us” – she’s my boss, by the way – and if she says, “I didn’t read the case today,” I say, “Okay, you weren’t here today. You’re marked as not present.” Because you have to force people to prepare, and they do instrumental work.

You have to force them to work in groups. You get students who say, “But I want to do this project by myself.” And I say, “No, that’s not an option. It’s written in.” And we force students to solve real problems. Every year, when Chandler and I do our machine learning course, we have students who say, “But I want to work with a data set that’s already available.” And we say, you have to work with a real data set, because real data sets are not clean or well defined, or even available. Half the work for a data scientist is actually getting the data into a shape where you can analyse it. You have to force them to touch the dirty reality, and there are no exceptions.

Here’s a technique I learned from a colleague – I’ll get back to him later. When the students choose their term papers, this is the way we do it. Every student makes a handwritten poster where they present what they want to write about: which company, which problem they want to solve, and so on. They all present; it takes a minute or two each, depending on how many students we have. As soon as you’ve finished presenting, we glue the piece of paper up on the wall, so we have all these posters along the wall. When everybody’s done, everybody goes up and stands in front of their poster. I ask people to notice where everybody is, and then I declare the market open. And you have to find a group, and you have to do it there. That’s engagement. When I do that, two minutes later the classroom looks like this. And that’s what you want to see: students actively engaging, finding problems. And you have to force them to do it.

Another thing I do is that I tend not to emphasize theory, because theory you can find in other courses, and you can also find it online or elsewhere. It’s kind of normal to have a guest lecture or two. I do a lot more. This semester I have four courses, and these are the guest lectures booked so far. I go out and recruit all these business people and have them come in, and I don’t ask them to teach. I ask them to talk about what they do. So I asked Geir Karlsen, what’s it like to run Norwegian, and how did you manage to turn it around? Or I asked Torstein Berg how he’s been able to start and fund three or four very successful companies. Or I talked to Andreas Solbakken about his serial entrepreneurship since he was 16 years old. And these people come back, because they’re asked not to be teachers but to be business people. The whole thing is about providing an experience in the classroom that you can’t get online or through AI.

And then I collaborate, and I experiment with masters. I never teach alone. That’s expensive, again, so you’re going to have to fund this. But courses get much better if there are two of you. If you’ve ever listened to a podcast, you know there are two people, because they talk to each other and it becomes a conversation. And I find masters I can collaborate with.

So I have a master of interaction: the best case teacher I’ve ever met. His name is Bill Schiano. He’s not here; he’s at Bentley University. In 1996 we put together a course where we did video teaching across the Atlantic and had the students form groups across the Atlantic to solve business problems. That got us into Aftenposten, and eventually we wrote a book together called Teaching with Cases, with all sorts of tips and tricks for how to get this engagement.

Then I have a master of relevance – somebody who really knows business and can provide relevance. Her name is Berit Svendsen. When Berit resigned her job as CEO of Telenor Norway, I heard it on the radio, and I stopped the car and called Inge Jan Henjesand, the former president, and said, “Hire her.” And it’s the only time he has listened to me. We do a course called Det verdiskapende styret together, and I shamelessly use Berit for her relevance and her business connections. The first class we taught, she said, “I have to leave early, because there’s something going on.” We were teaching board management – and the day after, it was in the newspaper that she had become Board Chair of the Year.

I have a master of explanation. His name is Chandler Johnson. I didn’t know anything about machine learning – or I knew a little bit; I knew statistics – but I wanted to learn. And the best way to learn something is to do a course in it. So I set up a course in analytics, which gave Chandler access to business people and me access to Chandler. Now we’ve done it ten times, and now I can teach machine learning. That’s how you do it.

I have a master of diplomacy. His name is Stein Gjessing. For seven years I wanted to do a course that mixed real technology – computer science from the Department of Informatics at the University of Oslo – with the business part delivered by BI: the biggest university in Norway and the biggest business school, two stops away from each other on the train. How hard can it be? Turned out, very hard. But Stein shepherded this through a very sceptical faculty at the University of Oslo. I was not so successful shepherding it through a very sceptical organization here locally. So we had to do it at the university, and we called it Digital Economics and Management – first a bachelor’s, then a master’s – and it became Norway’s most popular programme: 3,000 applicants for 27 places. I got calls from parents saying, “Can you get my daughter in?” It’s still the most popular programme at the institute, and we made the front page of Dagens Næringsliv.

And last but not least, I have a master of innovation, and his name is Ragnvald Sannes – a master of innovation in teaching. We have done a lot of things together. He’s an expert in the process of setting up a course, and this whole process I use, of having students choose a project early and shepherding them through the whole class, I learned from him – including this trick with all the posters. If you want to see a really nice classroom, go and look at the Ragnvald Sannes auditorium, which is just over here. It hasn’t got that sign on the wall yet, but it will.

We have created lots of courses. The one that has been the most fun was the course we ran for 20 years called Strategic Business Development and Innovation. We did that together with Accenture in Sophia Antipolis, a technology park in the south of France. The side effect, of course, was that every October we had to go to Antibes for a week or two – and Egil was paying for it, or his predecessors – and we went with our wives and with Ellen Heggelund, who is a master course arranger. We did that for 20 years. It was a pain, but somebody had to do it…

What should higher education and BI do? Well, here’s a little list to think about. Here’s the thing: BI is already doing a lot. I’m not as worried about BI as I am about other institutions of higher learning. And the reason is very simple: we do not have two billion kroner in foundational funding. We have to – and we’re doing quite a bit.

We have a word called employability, which Egil has put on the agenda. That means we need to care a lot about our students getting jobs, because that is our contract. If you don’t know what to do, go to BI – you will get a job. That’s our unwritten contract. So employability is now on the agenda. What it is, I don’t know, but it’s on the agenda.

Secondly, we’re doing something called Doing Sustainable Business. I was going to be involved with it, but I got sick, and that really saddens me, because it is a fantastic course. It’s the final course at the end of the bachelor programme. It has three and a half thousand students doing cases in groups across study disciplines. And here’s the thing: I was at Harvard Business School about three years ago, discussing case teaching with them, and they talked about this programme and said nobody is doing that. We’re the only school in the world that does that. 70 faculty are involved. This is great. It’s expensive, Egil, so you’re going to have to continue funding it, because it’s important.

We have this building. This building has classrooms where the students can see each other. This building is beautiful. This building is interactive. This building is clean. When I go to certain other institutions, I have to bring my own markers, because there are no markers in the classroom. Here, people test the markers every morning to make sure they work. We have the infrastructure. People go to other institutions in Oslo, look around at brutalist concrete buildings, and then they come here and think, “Hmm – the next five years of my life.” This building is, if not the most important, at least the most visible competitive advantage we have. I’ve tried to do case teaching in classrooms where students can only look straight ahead. That’s not easy. We have U-shaped classrooms. We have the technology, we have the infrastructure, and we understand the severity of the problem. And that’s important.

But we need to change things, and here are the things I think we need to change. We need to change recruitment and rewards. We need to reward teaching, teaching innovation and teaching development as much as we do research. Why is it called “undervisningsplikt”? Get rid of that word. It’s something you do – it’s the main thing we do.

We must change the innovation process from stage-gate to experimental. When I teach innovation – or rather, when Ragnvald teaches innovation – we talk about old processes, where you come up with an idea, present it to a committee, and they decide yes or no; and more modern processes, where you develop a prototype and test it in the market. And it’s kind of weird to me that we are using the old model and not the new one. Because almost all innovation at BI has happened because somebody just did it. One of the reasons we rank so high is that we have a Chinese programme, and the Chinese programme was done by a couple of faculty who just went there and did it. There was no formal gate process. So we have to be able to experiment.

We must oppose regulation that shackles innovation. One of the problems we have with AI is that we need to change the way we do evaluation. If you go to Harvard, MIT, IMD, INSEAD, Darden or London Business School, you’re evaluated based on what you say in the classroom. In Norway, we’re not allowed to do that. The best universities in the world do it. We must do something about that. We must stop this notion that grading is a controllable and measurable process. It is opinion.

And we must tolerate innovation even if we don’t like it – even if we don’t like the person. Remember that article about the guns? One of the reasons it took 30 years was that the guy who improved gunnery from 7% to 80%, or something like that, was an arrogant bastard. Nobody liked him. Another reason was that he had the gunner decide himself when to fire, rather than an officer saying “fire”. You had to compensate for the ship rolling, and the gunner could actually do that – which meant transferring the decision right from the people who traditionally had it. We can’t do that. We have to test in the market and then do what works.

So what we essentially have to do – and I’ve used this term many times, but I think it’s very, very important – is protect the future from the past. Otherwise, we end up holding horses.

Thank you very much!

NATO in an unstable present

Diplomacy, Democracy, Defence and the Future of the Transatlantic Relationship
Olav & Oddvar Dyvik Memorial Lecture by Former Ambassador and Current Harvard Kennedy School Professor Nicholas Burns.

Prof. Burns opens with a story of how King Harald lived in the White House for five years, learning to fish from FDR and standing behind him at his fourth inauguration. Norway and the US both founders of NATO, to make sure something like the second world war would never happen again.

He starts his talk with 9/11, when he as a very new ambassador to NATO, where noone knew what to do – and the Canadian and Danish and German and Norwegian ambassadors called to say that they wanted to invoke article five – willing to fight with the USA. As Condoleeza Rice said: It is good to have friends. Now, he fears, that his country is risking it all – especially the threat from president Trump towards Denmark and Canada, his end of the military support for Ukraine, and befriending Putin. America is living through a crisis about who we are. Our president has broken the bonds of trust with our allies, and that is deeply painful to millions and Americans. in the coming months and years we will be tested, and need to rediscover and reconfirm our commitment to democracy.

We need a stronger Europe, to help Ukraine, to defend its cities against missiles. We must be as modern as the authoritarian powers – Iran and Russia. There is also the issue of democracy defense – witness the very disappointing result in Germany today. Li Jiping says the East is rising, the West is falling. I don’t think so, but we must show it in practice, by standing up for our values.

We can find our way towards redemption, become again the allies we need to be.

Q and A:

What is the balance in the House and Senate when it comes to NATO? Most are very pro NATO – law passed that NATO exit would require 2/3 majority in the House.

Where do you see China going on climate change? Don’t underestimate China – they are to a large extent meritocratic, with very highly educated leaders, mainly engineers. They are building the Silk Road, and want to create a shipping lane north fo Russia.

What is the risk of article five not being supported by all countries of NATO, particularly the USA? That depends on the scenario. Putin has been cutting cables, flown drones across the borders, etc. Worried about Estonia and Latvia, 25% ethnic Russians. The short answer is I don’t know, and that is not a good answer.

If you were in charge, how should the US use diplomacy to end this war? Putin understand strength, he respected Biden because he was a solid supporter of Ukraine. None of the two warring parties will win in a traditional sense, but the manpower is in Russias favour. The best result we can hope for is to have a peace more or less along the lines of occupation, nothing more.

Post-Trump, in 2028, how much damage has he done and how much can he do? How should Europe and Norway handle him? Støre and Stoltenberg did well, disagreed when they had to, but kept the relationship going.

From a young American: The WWII version of America seems quite distant to a post-9/11 person – we seem to be the bullies. What are the current heroes that we should emulate. Politicians are beginning to speak to the modern issues: Home affordability, fear of AI, climate change, inflation. Look at John Ossof, new senator from Georgia, as well as senator Schumer. My daughter admires AOC. A younger generation is coming, and they are welcome.

From the ambassador of Chile: What is your view concerning nuclear deterrence in Europe? Can they still rely on USA? Good question – German is looking to France and the UK to provide the nuclear umbrella for Germany. In the 2030s China and Russia will outnumber USA in terms of offensive nuclear weapons. Hypersonic nuclear missiles will reduce the time leaders have to talk.

There is insecurity about NATO, also because of developments in Norway – is it wise to develop a plan B, a coalition of the willing? I think that is a good idea. 33 countries will not always agree.

From a young person: Why are they rising? We are proud democracies – authoritative regimes run on power.

Kennedy student, since 2024, professors there talk like Trump is temporary – what if he is not and this is a structural shift in US foreign policy? Very difficult question. Immigration and AI will be contested issues. Cyber, biotech and quantum computing will be contested. What has changed is the incivility in our public discourse. We have lost the ability to talk to each other respectfully. We need leaders who will unite us, not divide us.

Norwegian reserve officer: You referenced a possible agreement like the Korean in Ukraine. Could Russia use this as a resting period to come back and attack later? In my heart of hearts, I would like Ukraine to win, but the rational side of me thinks we need to cut the losses, Ukraine cannot defend their cities now. I worry that the US negotiators will favor Russia. And it is president Zelensky’s decision. The US negotiators have been to Russia 10 times, in Ukraine once.

About being in the world

(An edited translation of this Norwegian blogpost, for the benefit of my non-Norwegian students.)

I’m currently reading and discussing a lot about artificial intelligence (like everyone else, for that matter, but I’m on a sabbatical and new – in this case, not so new – technologies are what I’m working on and teaching about.)

One of the reflections I have about it is “wow, so little has changed.”

I first got into the discussion about artificial intelligence in the 80s, when I worked in the IT department at BI and was lucky enough to have a boss (Erling Iversen) who read a lot and was plugged into the AI ​​discussion as it was then. Through him, Fred Wenstøp, and eventually Charles Stabell and Øystein Fjeldstad, I was introduced to books like Heins Pagel’s Dreams of Reason, Bolter’s Turing’s Man, Hofstadter’s Gödel, Escher, Bach (as Erling used to say, “there are two kinds of IT people, those who have read Hofstadter and those who have not.”), Rumelhart and McLelland’s Parallel Distributed Processing and somewhat later Resnick’s Turtles, Termites and Traffic Jams. (Blogged about here.)

All of these books, and the ideas they contain, can help us understand what artificial intelligence is and how we should handle it. That understanding is important, because today AI is starting to become commonplace (much like PCs in the late 80s, the internet in the second half of the 90s, mobile and social media in the 2000s) and I see in any case that the same misunderstandings and expectations that were prevalent then also apply to AI.

Then it might be worth looking at some previous discussions about AI, because almost all the arguments you see have been made before and have not lost their validity, even though language models can now be run rather than just described.

The most important criticism of AI – and especially whether machines could ever achieve some form of intelligence – came from Hubert Dreyfus, a philosopher who questioned many of the assumptions that underpinned the idea that if a machine becomes powerful enough, it will become smart. Dreyfus articulated early on what is becoming clearer and clearer as neural networks become commonplace: That the brain is not a computer, even though parts of it can be simulated by a neural network without context; and that a neural network is not a brain, even though it can produce something that at first glance looks like intelligence. Thinking is not computation, and computation is not thinking, quite simply.

I found a film on YouTube the other day that describes and illustrates many of Hubert’s points, especially that knowledge is created in a context and cannot be reproduced freely from it. The film takes a number of artists and others with deep knowledge, and shows how that knowledge and the results of it occur in interaction with both one’s own body and the environment. As Dreyfus says in the film: “the source of meaning in our lives isn’t in us – that’s the Cartesian tradition – and it isn’t in some supreme being, but it is in our way of being in the world.” (https://youtu.be/fcCRmf_tHW8?t=4629).

I find one of the statements particularly interesting: “One of the dangers of technology is that it relieves us of the necessity of developing skills.” Ideas and knowledge often come as a result of limitations, of obstacles that one must overcome. With the shorter and shorter distance between desire and fulfilment, will we all end up as spoiled brats?

Probably not, because we want context and interaction.

Plus ça change, plus c’est la meme chose…

Two (well, five) book recommendations from 2023

BI’s China office asked me to recommend two books I have read in 2023 to their students, so here goes (with a few honorable mentions):

Flyvbjerg, Bent & Dan Gardner (2023): How Big Things Get Done: The Surprising Factors That Determine the Fate of Every Project, from Home Renovations to Space Exploration and Everything In Between
This excellent book dives into why big projects (in particular, big IT projects) so often fail; i.e., they come in late, more expensive and less complete than they were supposed to be. There are many solutions to this problem, but these authors discuss them carefully and advocates modularization – dividing things up into understandable and managable chunks – as the chief solution. They do so without coming up with any kind of magical method, instead using lots of examples to help you learn. Clearly written, a pleasure to read. Highly recommended!

Miller, Chris (2022): Chip War: The Fight for the World’s Most Critical Technology, Scribner.
This is an excellent book on the evolution of the microchip industry and a great discussion of the interwoven nature of chip production, design and distribution. Shows how a seemingly mundane industry can become not just strategic for business people, but for politicians and, eventually, nations. Also a good illustration of value chain evolution – how profits move from one element of the value chain (design) to others (production, production equipment) and as such a book i can refer to when teaching disruption.

And here are some honorable mentions:

Stephen Wolfram (2023): What is ChatGPT doing … and how does it work?
Very complete explanation on precisely what the title says. As usual, wolfram becomes a bit too detailed sometimes and endlessly promotes his view of the world as algorithm-driven, but this is interesting and, at least for the parts that explains ChatGPT, very informative.

Zeke Faux (2023): Number Go Up: Inside Crypto’s Wild Rise and Staggering Fall
A colleague of min took sick, so I had to teach a couple classes on cryptography, Bitcoin and other fashionable topics. The best book about latest wave turned out not to be (as I expected) Michael Lewis’ Going Infinite (he may have been a bit too close to his subject), but Zeke Faux’ excellent exposé of the feverish rise of various shitcoins and ditto exchanges. The best bits is when he pokes into the slave-labor economics of scam houses, where people are literally kidnapped and enslaved to try to scam you to invest in various things with X’s in their names. Dot-com all over again….and excellent reading for students who think they have discovered the next great thing.

Greimel, Hans and William Sposato (2021): Collision Course: Carlos Ghosn and the Culture Wars That Upended an Auto Empire
This is the story of Carlos Ghosn, who came in as a saviour for Nissan (in the process exposing much of Japan’s unwillingness to communicate or even think about bad news), merging it with Renault, and barely making it out of the country when he ran afoul of culture, conventions and the ministry of something or other. A proper swashbuckling business tale, entertaining and interesting in a thank-God-I-don’t-work-there kind of way. (And yes, not a 2023 book, but I read it that year.)

AI caution – explained

I hear so much weird stuff about AI these days that I tend to just block it out – including people talking about “an AI” as in “we need an AI for that”. So if it quite fun when John Oliver more or less nails it in this widely viewed video:

(And, well, with more than 3 million views and counting, it is not like he needs the mention. But my puny little intelligence need a place to store my references, and this blog is as good as any other place…)

On videoconferencing and security

Picture: Zoom

Yesterday began with a message from a business executive who was concerned with the security of Zoom, the video conferencing platform that many companies (and universities) have landed on. The reason was a newspaper article regurgitating several internet articles, partly about functionality that has been adequately documented by Zoom, partly about security holes that have been fixed a long time ago.

So is there any reason to be concerned about Zoom or Whereby or Teams or Hangouts or all the other platforms?

My answer is “probably not” – at least not for the security holes discussed here, and for ordinary users (and that includes most small- to medium sized companies I know about).

It is true that video conferencing introduces some security and privacy issues, but if we look at it realistically, the biggest problem is not the technology, but the people using it (Something we nerds refer to as PEBKAC – Problem Exists Between Keyboard and Chair.)

When a naked man sneaks into an elementary school class via Whereby, as happened a few days ago here in Norway, it is not due to technology problems, but because the teacher had left the door wide open, i.e., had not turned on the function that makes it necessary to “knock” and ask for permission to enter.

When anyone can record (and have the dialogue automatically transcribed) from Zoom, it is because the host has not turned off the recording feature. By the way, anyone can record a video conference with screen capture software (such as Camtasia), a sound recorder or for that matter a cell phone, and no (realistic) security system in the world can do anything about it.

When the boss can monitor that people are not using other software while sitting in a meeting (a feature that can be completely legitimate in a classroom, it is equivalent to the teacher looking beyond the class to see if the students are awake), well, I don’t think the system is to blame for that either. Any leader who holds such irrelevant meetings that people do not bother to pay attention should rethink their communications strategy. Any executive I know would have neither time nor interest in activating this feature – because if you need technology to force people to wake up, you don’t have a problem technology can solve.

The risk of a new tool should not be measured against some perfect solution, but against what the alternative is if you don’t have it. Right now, video conferencing is the easiest and best tool for many – so that is why we use it. But we have to take the trouble to learn how it works. The best security system in the world is helpless against people writing their password on a Post-It, visible when they are in videoconference.

So, therefore – before using the tool – take a tour of the setup page, choose carefully what features you want to use, and think through what you want to achieve by having the meeting.

If that’s hard, maybe you should cancel the whole thing and send an email instead.

Getting dialogue online

Bank in the nineties, I facilitated a meeting with Frank Elter at a Telenor video meeting room in Oslo. There were about 8 participants, and an invited presenter: Tom Malone from MIT.

The way it was set up, we first saw a one hour long video Tom had created, where he gave a talk and showed some videos about new ways of organizing work (one of the more memorable sequences was (a shortened version of) the four-hour house video.) After seeing Tom’s video, we spent about one hour discussing some of the questions Tom had raised in the video. Then Tom came on from a video conferencing studio in Cambridge, Massachusetts, to discuss with the participants.

The interesting thing, to me, was that the participants experienced this meeting as “three hours with Tom Malone”. Tom experienced it as a one hour discussion with very interested and extremely well prepared participants.

A win-win, in other words.

I was trying for something similar yesterday, guest lecturing in Lene Pettersen‘s course at the University of Oslo, using Zoom with early entry, chat, polling and all video/audio enabled for all participants. This was the first videoconference lecture for the students and for three of my colleagues, who joined in. In preparation, the students had read some book chapters and articles and watched my video on technology evolution and disruptive innovations.

For the two hour session, I had set up this driving plan (starting at 2 pm, or 14:00 as we say over here in Europe…):

Image may contain: Espen Andersen, eyeglasses

Leading the discussion. Zoom allows you to show a virtual background, so I chose a picture of the office I would have liked to have…

14:00 – 14:15 Checking in, fiddling with the equipment and making sure everything worked. (First time for many of the users, so have the show up early so technical issues don’t eat into the teaching time.)
14:15 – 14:25 Lene introduces the class, talks about the rest of the course and turns over to Espen (we also encouraged the students to enter questions they wanted addressed in the chat during this piece)
14:25 – 14:35 Espen talking about disruption and technology-driven strategies.
14:35 – 14:55 Students into breakout rooms – discussing whether video what it would take for video and digital delivery to be a disruptive innovation for universities. (Breaking students up into 8 rooms of four participants, asking them to nominate a spokesperson to take notes and paste them into the chat when they return, and to discuss the specific question: What needs to happen for COVID-19 to cause a disruption of universities, and how would such a disruption play out?
14:55 – 15:15 Return to main room, Espen sums up a little bit, and calls on spokesperson from each group (3 out of 8 groups) based on the notes posted in the chat (which everyone can see). Espen talks about the Finn.no case and raises the next discussion question.
15:15 – 15:35 Breakout rooms, students discuss the next question: What needs to happen for DNB (Norway’s largest bank) to become a data-driven, experiment-oriented organization like Finn.no? What are the most important obstacles and how should they be dealt with?
15:35 – 15:55 Espen sums up the discussion, calling on some students based on the posts in the chat, sums up.
15:55 – 16:00 Espen hand back to Lene, who sums up. After 16:00, we stayed on with colleagues and some of the students to discuss the experience.

zoom dashboard

The dashboard as I saw it. Student names obscured.

Some reflections (some of these are rather technical, but they are notes to myself):

  • Not using Powerpoint or a shared screen is important. Running Zoom in Gallery view (I had set it up so you could see up to 49 at the same time) and having the students log in to Zoom and upload a picture gave a feeling of community. Screen and/or presentation sharing breaks the flow for everyone – When you do it in Zoom, the screen reconfigures (as it does when you come back from a breakout room) and you have to reestablish the participant panel and the chat floater. Instead, using polls and discussion questions and results communicated through the chat was easier for everyone (and way less complicated).
  • No photo description available.

    Satisfactory results, I would say.

    I used polls on three occasions: Before each discussion breakout, and in the end to ask the students what the experience was like. They were very happy about it and had good pointers on how to make it better

  • We had no performance issues and rock-steady connection the whole way through.
  • It should be noted that the program is one of the most selective in Norway and the students are highly motivated and very good. During the breakout sessions I jumped into each room to listen in on the discussion (learned that it was best to pause recording to avoid a voice saying “This session is being recorded” as I entered. The students were actively discussing in every group, with my colleagues (Bendik, Lene, and Katja) also participating. I had kept the groups to four participants, based on feedback from a session last week, where the students had been 6-7 and had issues with people speaking over each other.
  • Having a carefully written driving plan was important, but still, it was a very intense experience, I was quite exhausted afterwards. My advice on not teaching alone stands – in this case, I was the only one with experience, but that will change very fast. But I kept feeling rushed and would have liked more time, especially in the summary sections, would have liked to bring more students in to talk.
  • I did have a few breaks myself – during the breakout sessions – to go to the bathroom and replenish my coffee – but failed to allow for breaks for the students. I assume they managed to sneak out when necessary (hiding behind a still picture), but next time, I will explicitly have breaks, perhaps suggest a five minute break in the transition from main room to breakout rooms.

Conclusion: This can work very well, but I think it is important to set up each video session based on what you want to use it for: To present something, to run an exercise, to facilitate interaction. With a small student group like this, I think interaction worked very well, but it requires a lot of presentation. You have to be extremely conscious of time – I seriously think that any two-hour classroom session needs to be rescheduled to a three hour session just because the interaction is slower, and you need to have breaks.

As Winston Churchill almost said (he said a lot, didn’t he): We make our tools, and then our tools make us. We now have the tools, it will be interesting to see how the second part of this transition plays out.

Summer reading for the diligent digital technology student

eivindg

Eivind Grønlund, one of my students at the Informatics: Digital Business and Leadership program at the University of Oslo sent me an email asking about what to read during the summer to prepare for the fall.

Well, I don’t believe in reading textbooks in the summer, I believe in reading things that will excite you and make you think about what you are doing and slightly derail you in a way that will make you a more interesting person when Fall comes. In other words, read whatever you want.

That being said, the students at DigØk have two business courses next year – one on organization and leadership, one on technology evolution and strategy. Both will have a a focus on basics, with a flavor of high tech and the software business. What can you read to understand that, without having to dig into textbooks or books that may be on the syllabus, like Leading Digital, The Innovator’s Solution, Enterprise Architecture as Strategy, or Information Rules?

Here are four books that are entertaining and wise and will give you an understanding of how humans and technology interact and at least some of the difficulties you will run into trying to manage them – but in a non-schoolbook context. Just the thing for the beach, the mountain-top, the sailboat.

  • 816
    Neal Stephenson: Cryptonomicon. The ultimate nerd novel. A technology management friend of mine re-reads this book every summer. It involves history, magic reality (the character of Enoch Root), humor, startup lore, encryption and, well, fun. Several stories in one: About a group of nerds (main protagonist: Randy Waterhouse) doing a startup in Manila and other places 1999, his grandfather, Randall P. Waterhouse, running cryptographic warfare against the Germans and Japanese during WWII, and how the stories gradually intersect and come together towards the end. The gallery of characters is hilarious and fascinating, and you can really learn something about startups, nerd culture, programming, cryptography and history along the way. Highly recommended.
  • 7090
    Tracy Kidder: The Soul of a New Machine. This 1981 book describes the development process of a Data General minicomputer as a deep case study of the people in it. It could just as well have been written about any really advanced technology project today – the characters, the challenges, the little subcultures that develop within a highly focused team stretching the boundaries for what is possible. One of the best case studies ever written. If you want to understand how advanced technology gets made, this is it.
  • 24113
    Douglas Hofstadter: Gödel, Escher, Bach. This book (aficionados just call it GEB) was recommended to me by one of my professors in 1983, and is responsible for me wanting to be in academia and have time and occasion to read books such as this one. It is also one of the reasons I think The Matrix is a really crap movie – Hofstadter said it all before, and I figured out the plot almost at once and thought the whole thing a tiresome copycat. Hofstader writes about patterns, abstractions, the concept of meta-phenomena, but mostly the book is about self-referencing systems, but as with any good book that makes you think it is breath-taking in what it covers, pulling together music, art, philosophy and computer science (including a bit on encryption, always a favorite) and history. Not for the faint-hearted, but as Erling Iversen, my old boss and an extremely well-read man, said: You can divide techies into two kinds: Those who have read Hofstadter, and those who haven’t.
  • 34017076
    Tim O’Reilly: WTF? What’s the Future and Why It’s Up to Us. Tim is the founder of O’Reilly and Associates (the premier source of hands-on tech books for me) and has been a ringsider and a participant in anything Internet and digital tech since the nineties. This fairly recent book provides a good overview of the major evolutions and battles during the last 10-15 years and is a great catcher-upper for the young person who has not been been part of the revolution (so far.)

And with that – have a great summer!

The history of software engineering

grady_booch2c_chm_2011_2_cropped

The History of Software Engineering
an ACM webinar presentation by
ACM Fellow Grady Booch, Chief Scientist for Software Engineering, IBM Software
(PDF slides here.)

Note: These are notes taken while listening to this webinar. Errors, misunderstandings and misses aplenty…

(This is one of the perks of being a member of ACM – listening to legends of the industry talking about how it got started…)

Trust is fundamental – and we trust engineering because of licensing and certification. This is not true of software systems – and that leads us to software engineering. Checks and balances important – Hammurabi code of buildings, for instance. First licensed engineer was Charles Bellamy, in Wyoming, in 1907, largely because of former failures of bridges, boilers, dams, etc.

Systems engineering dates back to Bell labs, early 1940s, during WWII. In some states you can declare yourself a software engineer, in others licensing is required, perhaps because the industry is young. Computers were, in the beginning, human (mostly women). Stibitz coined digital around 1942, Tukey coined software in 1952. 1968-69 conference on software engineering coined the term, but CACM letter by Anthony Oettinger used the term in 1966, but the term was used before that (“systems software engineering”), most probably originated by Margaret Hamilton in 1963, working for Draper Labs.

Programming – art or science? Hopper, Dijkstra, Knuth, sees them as practical art, art, etc. Parnas distinguished between computer science and software engineering. Booch sees it as dealing with forces that are apparent when designing and building software systems. Good engineering based on discovery, invention, and implementation – and this has been the pattern of software engineering – dance between science and implementation.

Lovelace first programmer, algorithmic development. Boole and boolean algebra, implementing raw logic as “laws of thought”.

First computers were low cost assistants to astronomers, establishing rigorous processes for acting on data (Annie Cannon, Henrietta Leavitt.) Scaling of problems and automation towards the end of the 1800s – rows of (human) computers in a pipeline architecture. The Gilbreths created process charts (1921). Edith Clarke (1921) wrote about the process of programming. Mechanisation with punch cards (Gertrude Blanch, human computing, 1938; J Presper Eckert on punch car methods (1940), first methodology with pattern languages.

Digital methods coming – Stibitz, Von Neumann, Aitken, Goldstein, Grace Hopper with machine-independent programming in 1952, devising languages and independent algorithms. Colossus and Turing, Tommy Flowers on programmable computation, Dotthy du Boisson with workflow (primary operator of Colossus), Konrad Zuse on high order languages, first general purpose stored programs computer. ENIAC with plugboard programming, dominated by women, (Antonelli, Snyder, Spence, Teitelbaum, Wescoff). Towards the end of the war: Kilburn real-time (1948), Wilson and Gill subroutines (1949), Eckert and Mauchly with software as a thing of itself (1949). John Bacchus with imperative programming (Fortran, 1946), Goldstein and von Neumann flowcharts (1947). Commercial computers – Leo for a tea company in England. John Pinkerton creating operating system, Hoper with ALGOL and COBOL, reuse (Bener, Sammet). SAGE system important, command and control – Jay Forrester and Whirlwind 1951, Bob Evans (Sage, 1957), Strachey time sharing 1959, St Johnson with the first programming services company (1959).

Software crisis – not enough programmers around, machines more expensive than the humans, priesthood of programming, carry programs over and get results, batch. Fred Brooks on project management (1964), Constantin on modular programming (1968), Dijkstra on structured programming (1969). Formal systems (Hoare and Floyd) and provable programs; object orientation (Dahl and Nygaard, 1967). Main programming problem was complexity and productivity, hence software engineering (Margaret Hamilton) arguing that process should be managed.

Royce and the waterfall method (1970), Wirth on stepwise refinement, Parnas on information hiding, Liskov on abstract data types, Chen on entity-relationship modelling. First SW engineering methods: Ross, Constantine, Yourdon, Jackson, Demarco. Fagin on software inspection, Backus on functional programming, Lamport on distributed computing. Microcomputers made computing cheap – second generation of SW engineering: UML (Booch 1986), Rumbaugh, Jacobsen on use cases, standardization on UML in 1997, open source. Mellor, Yourdon, Worfs-Brock, Coad, Boehm, Basils, Cox, Mills, Humphrey (CMM), James Martin and John Zachman from the business side. Software engineering becomes a discipline with associations. Don Knuth (literate programming), Stallman on free software, Cooper on visual programming (visual basic).

Arpanet and Internet changed things again: Sutherland and SCRUM, Beck on eXtreme prorgamming, Fowler and refactoring, Royce on Rational Unified Process. Software architecture (Kruchten etc.), Reed Hastings (configuration management), Raymond on open source, Kaznik on outsourcing (first major contract between GE and India).

Mobile devices changed things again – Torvalds and git, Coplien and organiational patterns, Wing and computational thinking, Spolsky and stackoverflow, Robert Martin and clean code (2008). Consolidation into cloud: Shafer and Debois on devops (2008), context becoming important. Brad Cox and componentized structures, service-oriented architectures and APIs, Jeff Dean and platform computing, Jeff Bezos.

And here we are today: Ambient computing, systems are everywhere and surround us. Software-intensive systems are used all the time, trusted, and there we are. Computer science focused on physics and algorithms, software engineering on process, architecture, economics, organisation, HCI. SWEBOK first 2004, latest 2014, codification.

Mathematical -> Symbolic -> Personal -> Distributed & Connected -> Imagined Realities

Fundamentals -> Complexity -> HCI -> Scale -> Ethics and morals

Scale is important – risk and cost increases with size. Most SW development is like engineering a city, you have to change things in the presence of things that you can’t change and cannot change. AI changes things again – symbolic approaches and connectionist approaches, such as Deepmind. Still a lot we don’t know what to do – such as architecture for AI, little rigorous specification and testing. Orchestration of AI will change how we look at systems, teaching systems rather than programming them.

Fundamentals always apply: Abstraction, separation, responsibilities, simplicity. Process is iterative, incremental, continuous releases. Future: Orchestrating, architecture, edge/cloud, scale in the presence of untrusted components, dealing with the general product.

“Software is the invisible writing that whispers the stories of possibility to our hardware…” Software engineering allows us to build systems that are trusted.

Sources: https://twitter.com/Grady_Booch, https://computingthehumanexperience.com/

Brilliance squared

Stephen Fry and Steven Pinker are two of the people I admire the most, for their erudition, extreme levels and variety of learning, and willingness to discuss their ideas. Having them both on stage at the same time, one interviewing the other (on the subject of Pinker’s last book, Enlightenment Now), is almost too much, but here they are:

(I did, for some reason, receive an invitation to this event, and would have gone there despite timing and expense if at all possible, but it was oversubscribed before I could clink the link. So thank whomever for Youtube, I say. It can be used to spread enlightenment, too.)

Interesting interview with Rodney Brooks

sawyer_and_baxterBoingboing, which is a fantastic source of interesting stuff to do during Easter vacation, has a long and fascinating interview by Rob Reid with Rodney Brooks, AI and robotics researcher and entrepreneur extraordinaire. Among the things I learned:

  • What the Baxter robot really does well – interacting with humans and not requiring 1/10 mm precision, especially when learning
  • There are not enough workers in manufacturing (even in China), most of the ones working there spend their time waiting for some expensive capital equipment to finish
  • The automation infrastructure is really old, still using PLCs that refresh and develop really slowly
  • Robots will be important in health care – preserving people’s dignity by allowing them to drive and stay at home longer by having robots that understand force and softness and can do things such as help people out of bed.
  • He has written an excellent 2018 list of dated predictions on the evolution of robotic and AI technologies, highly readable, especially his discussions on how to predict technologies and that we tend to forget the starting points. (And I will add his blog to my Newsblur list.)
  • He certainly doesn’t think much of the trolley problem, but has a great example to understand the issue of what AI can do, based on what Isaac Newton would think if he were transported to our time and given a smartphone – he would assume that it would be able to light a candle, for instance.

Worth a listen..

Neural networks – explained

As mentioned here a few times, I teach an executive course called Analytics for strategic management, as well as a short program (three days) called Decisions from Data: Driving an Organization on Analytics. We have just finished the first version of both of these courses, and it has been a very enjoyable experience. The students (in both courses) have been interested and keen to learn, bringing relevant and interesting problems to the table, and we have managed do what it said on the tin (I think) – make them better consumers of analytics, capable of having a conversation with the analytics team, employing the right vocabulary and being able to ask more intelligent questions.

Of course, programs of this type does not allow you do dive deep into how things work, though we have been able to demonstrate MySQL, Python and DataRobot, and also give the students an understanding of how rapidly these things are evolving. We have talked about deep learning, for instance, but not how it works.

But that is easy to fix – almost everything about machine learning is available on Youtube and in other web channels, once you are into a little bit of the language. For instance, to understand how deep learning works, you can check out a series of videos from Grant Sanderson, who produces very good educational videos on the web site 3 blue one brown.

(There are follow-up videos: Chapter 2, Chapter 3, and Chapter 3 (formal calculus appendix). This Youtube channel has a lot of other math-related videos, too, including a great explanation of how Bitcoin works, which I’ll have to get into at some points, since I keep being asked why I don’t invest in Bitcoin all the time.)

Of course, you have to be rather interested to dive into this, and it certainly is not required read for an executive who only wants to be able to talk intelligently to the analytics team. But it is important (and a bit reassuring) to note the mechanisms employed: Breaking a very complex problem up into smaller problems, breaking those up into even smaller problems. solving the small problems by programming, then stepping back up. For those of you with high school math: It really isn’t that complicated. Just complicated in layers.

And it is good to know that all this advanced AI stuff really is rather basic math. Just applied in an increasingly complex way, really fast.

The nastiness of immigrant fear

This piece (http://crookedtimber.org/2017/10/23/working-to-rule/) by Maria (Farrell?) is a long and very insightful read about the emotional impact on immigrants from the Brexit debacle – and more generally, about the nastiness of reducing immigrants (or, for that matter, any foreigner) to a number and a category.

Anyone who thinks being an immigrant, even a deluxe EU three million-type immigrant, is easy, should try it. We compete on equal terms with all comers, but with no social or economic safety net and, for many, hustling like mad in second and third languages. No dole, no network of couches to sleep on, no contacts and no introductions; qualifications from institutions you’ve never heard of, references from employers you aren’t sure are real but can’t be bothered to check, acting as daily fodder for stereotypical jokes we laugh off to show we’re one of you. You don’t hear us complaining about it because it’s just part of the deal. But when the terms of the deal change, and you tell us we’re social welfare parasites who are also, somehow, taking all the jobs and are the reason the country is failing, then the deal is probably dead.

How anyone can think shutting yourself off from the world and fantasise about going back to a nonexistent 1960s idyll is in any way beneficial is beyond me. And this nastiness is not limited to Britain or Trump’s USA, far from it, Norway has its share of little people with big fears as well.

To get new ideas, increase the variety of sources, expose yourself to new experiences, and embrace that which you cannot understand.

Assuming you want new ideas, of course.

A tour de Fry of technology evolution

There are many things to say about Stephen Fry, but enough is to show this video, filmed at Nokia Bell Labs, explaining, amongst other things, the origin of microchips, the power of exponential growth, the adventure and consequences of performance and functionality evolution. I am beginning to think that “the apogee, the acme, the summit of human intelligence” might actually be Stephen himself:

(Of course, the most impressive feat is his easy banter on hard questions after the talk itself. Quotes like: “[and] who is to program any kind of moral [into computers ]… If [the computer] dives into the data lake and learns to swim, which is essentially what machine learning is, it’s just diving in and learning to swim, it may pick up some very unpleasant sewage.”)

Science fiction and the future

I am on the editorial board of ACM Ubiquity – and we are in the middle of a discussion of whether science fiction authors get things right or not, and whether science fiction is a useful predictor of the future. I must admit I am not a huge fan of science fiction – definitely not films, which tend to contain way too many scenes of people in tights staring at screens. But I do have some affinity for the more intellectual variety which tries to say something about our time by taking a single element of it and magnifying it.

So herewith, a list of technology-based science fiction short stories available on the web, a bit of fantasy in a world where worrying about the future impact of technology is becoming a public sport:

  • The machine stops by E. M. Forster is a classic about what happens when we make ourselves completely dependent on a (largely invisible) technology. Something to think about when you sit surfing and video conferencing  in your home office. First published in 1909, which is more than impressive.
  • The second variety by Philip K. Dick is about what happens when we develop self-organizing weapons systems – a future where warrior drones take over. Written as an extension of the cold war, but in a time where you can deliver a hand grenade with a drone bought for almost nothing at Amazon and remote-controlled wars initially may seem bloodless it behooves us to think ahead.
  • Jipi and the paranoid chip is a brilliant short story by Neal Stephenson – the only science-fiction author I read regularly (though much of what he writes is more historic/technothrillers than science fiction per se). The Jipi story is about what happens when technologies develop a sense of self and self preservation.
  • Captive audience by Ann Warren Griffith is perhaps not as well written as the others, but still: It is a about a society where we are not allowed not to watch commercials. And that should be scary enough for anyone bone tired of alle the intrusive ads popping up everywhere we go.

There is another one I would have liked to have on the list, but I can’t remember the title or the author. It is about a man living in a world where durable products are not allowed – everything breaks down after a certain time so that the economy is maintained because everyone has to buy new things all the time. The man is trying to smuggle home a wooden garden bench made for his wife out of materials that won’t degrade, but has trouble with a crumbling infrastructure and the wrapping paper dissolving unless he gets home soon enough…

Big Data and analytics – briefly

DFDDODData and data analytics is becoming more and more important for companies and organizations. Are you wondering what data and data science might do for your company? Welcome to a three-day ESP (Executive Short Program) called Decisions from Data: Driving an Organization with Analytics. It will take place at BI Norwegian Business School from December 5-7 this year. The short course is an offshoot from our very popular executive programs Analytics for Strategic Management, which are fully booked. (Check this list (Norwegian) for a sense of what those students are doing.)

Decisions from Data is aimed at managers who are curious about Big Data and data science and wants an introduction and an overview, without having to take a full course. We will talk about and show various forms of data analysis, discuss the most important obstacles to becoming a data driven organization and how to deal with data scientists, and, of course, give lots of examples of how to compete with analytics. The course will not be tech heavy, but we will look at and touch a few tools, just to get an idea of what we are asking those data scientists to do.

The whole thing will be in English, because, well, the (in my humble opinion) best people we have on this (Chandler Johnson og Alessandra Luzzi) are from the USA and Italy, respectively. As for myself, I tag along as best I can…

Welcome to the data revolution – it start’s here!

Singularity redux

From Danny Hillis: The Pattern on the Stone, which I am currently reading hunting for simple explanations of technological things:

Because computers can do some things that seem very much like human thinking, people often worry that they are threatening our unique position as rational beings, and there are some who seek reassurance in mathematical proofs of the limits of computers. There have been analogous controversies in human history. It was once considered important that the Earth be at the center of the universe, and our imagined position at the center was emblematic of our worth. The discovery that we occupied no central position – that  our planet was just one of a number of planets in orbit around the Sun – was deeply disturbing to many people at the time, and the philosophical implications of astronomy became a topic of heated debate. A similar controversy arose over evolutionary theory, which also appeared as a threat to humankind’s uniqueness. At the root of these earlier philosophical rises was a misplaced judgment of the source of human worth. I am convinced that most of the current philosophical discussions about the limits of computers are based on a similar misjudgment.

And that, I think, is one way to think about the future and intelligence, natural and artificial. Works for me, for now. No idea, of course, whether this still is Danny’s position, but I rather think it is.

Sapiens unite!

Sapiens: A Brief History of HumankindSapiens: A Brief History of Humankind by Yuval Noah Harari

My rating: 4 of 5 stars

This book (recommended by Grady Booch in his recent talk) attempts to give a brief history of mankind – specifically, Homo Sapiens, as opposed to Neanderthals and other hominids – in one book (a bit reminicent of Geoffrey Blainey’s A Short History of the World.) As such it is interesting, especially the early parts about the transition from hominids to collaborating humans and the cognitive revolution 70000 years ago. It is very clearly written – for instance, the chapter on capitalism and the importance of credit and creditworthiness is something I could hand out to my students directly as a brief explanation of what the fuzz is all about.) The book has been a success, and deservedly so – very rationalist, well informed, if a bit narrow in perspective here and there. The author seems to have a soft spot for hunter-gatherer societies (leading him to describe the agricultural revolution as a step backward for individuals, if not for the human race) and a digression on whether humans are more or less happy now (has historical progress done anything to our serotonine levels (answer: no, it hasn’t, which sort of renders the argument about agrarianism mot) veers towards ranting.

The best part is the way the author describes how much of history and out place in it now is based on inter-subjective fantasies – such as money, religion and states, which exist purely in our minds, because we agree between ourselves that they do.

And easy read, entertaining, and with quite a few very quotable passages here and there, for instance these on our bioengineered future:

Biologists the world over are locked in battle with the intelligent-design movement, which opposes the teaching of Darwinian evolution in schools and claims that biological complexity proves there must be a creator who thought out all biological details in advance. The biologists are right about the past, but the proponents of intelligent design might, ironically, be right about the future.

Most of the organisms now being engineered are those with the weakest political lobbies – plants, fungi, bacteria and insects.

Recommended.

View all my reviews

The thinking robot, again.

Interesting video, nice summary of a projection:

The creativity part is a bit further out. As for the horses, the ones left have a much better life than they used to have….

(Thanks for the tip, Rick Holmen!)